Acronos P52, 40 watt Ultralinear PP valve EN
Acronos P52, 40-watt ultralinear PP valve amplifier
Reverse-engineering report based on visual inspection of photographs and cross-checking against manufacturer catalogues. Images come from the video: Amplificador ACRONOS P52 Una obra de arte. Cómo se fabricó. and additional interior photographs provided by the unit's owner (2026-10).
In a nutshell: valve amplifier, 40 W nominal (manufacturer's figure), around 40 kg (personal comment, unverified). Clearly visible in the photos: 3 EPCOS B43645 electrolytics, with 610 µF legible on at least one (they would add up to 1,830 µF if all three were 610 µF and wired in parallel: conditional calculation); a vertical board (PCB-3) with 4 blue components, probably relays, of unknown function; a 10W10KJ resistor rated 10 kΩ / 10 W (it does not look compatible with a permanent B+ bleeder at 430 V under that hypothesis; its real function is unknown); and two blue trimmers (adjustment potentiometers) on the signal board PCB-S, one at each end. Probable, but unconfirmed: Hongfa HF115F relay, NE5532 chip and TL431 voltage reference; two 8-pin (DIP-8) chips are visible and the NE555 is not confirmed. Unknown: the function of the auxiliary magnetic element, the valve supply voltage (B+), their quiescent current (bias), the negative feedback (NFB), the percentage of ultralinear tap (%UL), the output impedance (Zout), the damping factor (DF) and the 1 % distortion power (P@1 %). Absolute priority: measure the P52's Zout and obtain photos of the underside of PCB-S.
GETTING STARTED — NO PRIOR KNOWLEDGE NEEDED (Basic guide G1–G6)
GETTING STARTED — NO PRIOR KNOWLEDGE NEEDED
If you have never opened a valve amplifier, start here. High-school physics (logarithms, electrical power, capacitors, impedance) is enough to understand why the figures in this report are stated with so much care. The technical details begin in Part I.
Basic guide: reading this report without being a valve expert
Central idea: no one has measured the Acronos P52, so we do not know how it actually performs. What we do know is what is visible inside and what a specific loudspeaker in a specific room actually demands. With those two pieces and a bit of physics you can reason without inventing data.
An amplifier takes the weak signal from the source (of the order of 1 V) and turns it into a signal with the voltage and current needed to drive the loudspeaker. In this unit that is done by thermionic valves in two blocks: a preamp, which raises the signal's voltage, and a power stage, which supplies the current. Everything is powered by a supply that produces a high DC voltage, called B+ (the "valve supply").
Source → Preamplifier → Power stage → Output transformer → Loudspeaker
(≈1 V) (voltage) (current) (impedance matching) (4–8 Ω)
↑
Power supply (B+)In the power stage the valves work in pairs in push-pull ("push-pull"): while one conducts more current, the other conducts less, and their currents combine in the output transformer. This has two physical advantages: the DC components of the two valves cancel out in the core (so it is not permanently magnetised) and many even harmonics cancel, which reduces distortion. The actual operating class (A, AB, B) of the P52's 6550s is classified as AB probable with AB1 probable subtype (§5.2); the exact bias mode (how the quiescent current is set) remains ND.
The output transformer acts as an "adapter": a power valve needs to see a load of thousands of ohms and a loudspeaker is only 4–8 Ω. With a turns ratio n, the impedance is multiplied by n². Illustrative example (not a P52 datum): with n = 25, an 8 Ω speaker is seen from the valves as 25² · 8 = 5000 Ω.
In an ultralinear (UL) arrangement, the valves' screen grids are connected to intermediate taps on the transformer. It is a compromise: pentode mode gives more power, triode mode gives less distortion. The manufacturer declares PP UL with 6550 (CONFIRMED (manufacturer)); the P52's actual %UL tap is ND.
This report is not a measurement: it starts from photographs of the manufacturer's video, component catalogues and public documentation. For this reason every claim carries an evidence label (the full legend is in the margin, and the method in §1):
| Label | What it means | Example in this report |
|---|---|---|
| OBSERVED | Directly visible in the photographs. | Silkscreen B43645-S7617-M1 on the HV capacitors. |
| PROBABLE | Reasonable physical inference, pending verification. | That the three capacitors are in parallel. |
| CALCULATED | Comes from a formula using known data. | 35.8 W to reach 95 dB at 3 m. |
| REPORTED-EXT | Data from a reliable third party without own measurement or official confirmation. | Nominal lifetime of the B43645 series. |
| MEASURED-EXT | Measured by an external laboratory. | Published figures for other equipment (context). |
| ND | Cannot be claimed with current evidence. | Zout and P@1 % of the P52. |
To decide whether an amplifier "has enough", start from the loudspeaker and the listening position. The decibel is a logarithmic scale: +10 dB multiplies power by 10 and +3 dB multiplies it by 2 (100.3 ≈ 1.995). The calculation proceeds with a generic reference system:
- Sensitivity. The reference loudspeaker produces 89 dB with 1 W at 1 m. HYPOTHESIS for the calculation, not measured.
- Distance. The level falls by 20·log₁₀(d) dB with distance. At 3 m: SPL(1 W, 3 m) = 89 − 20·log₁₀(3) = 89 − 9.54 = 79.46 dB.
- Power. To reach a level L: P = 10^((L − 79.46)/10). For 95 dB that gives 35.8 W with a single loudspeaker.
- Stereo. With two loudspeakers and a decorrelated stereo signal (the normal case in recorded music), acoustic powers add incoherently in a reverberant field: +3 dB. Each channel contributes half: 17.9 W/channel. Declared assumption: decorrelated signal. With a centred mono signal and on-axis listening, the sum would be coherent (+6 dB) and the power per channel would halve (~9 W), but that is not the usual case for music listening.
- Peaks. Music has peaks above its average level. A crest factor of 15 dB multiplies power by 101.5 ≈ 31.6. That is why the design has to be sized for the peak, not for the average: 80 dB average with 95 dB peaks.
Valves need a high DC voltage (B+) obtained by rectifying the mains. In Spain the mains is 50 Hz and, with a full-wave rectifier (a KBU1010 is observed in the P52), the ripple appears at 100 Hz. The filter capacitors charge on the voltage peaks and discharge between them. Since Q = C·ΔV and the time between peaks is 1/f, the voltage drop is approximately:
ΔV ≈ I / (f · C) (approximation: assumes constant current over the whole period and somewhat overestimates the real ripple)
Example with 200 mA and a 610 µF capacitor at 100 Hz: 0.2 / (100 · 610·10⁻⁶) ≈ 3.28 V peak-to-peak ripple. Three equal capacitors in parallel would add up to 1830 µF and give ≈ 1.09 V, but that only happens if they are in parallel, which has not been verified ND.
In addition to the capacitors, the P52 carried two toroids on the Rev.A board (the earlier revision) compatible with an inductive filter (C-L-C type). A coil opposes rapid current changes with a reactance XL = 2π·f·L. Illustrative example (not a P52 datum): a 1 H coil presents 628 Ω at 100 Hz. Without knowing L, its resistance and the load, it is impossible to quantify how much ripple they actually remove. Detail in §4.3.
A "6 Ω" loudspeaker is not always 6 Ω: its impedance changes with frequency. The reference loudspeaker dips to a minimum of 4.9 Ω around 1.4 kHz. An amplifier that behaves as a voltage source delivers more current when the impedance drops: with constant voltage, the current into 4.9 Ω is 6/4.9 ≈ 1.22 times the current into 6 Ω.
This is where the amplifier's output impedance (Zout) comes in, acting as a resistance in series with the loudspeaker. The damping factor is DF = Zload / Zout. Illustrative example (not a P52 datum): with Zout = 1.5 Ω, the voltage that reaches the loudspeaker is given by the divider Vspk = V · Zload / (Zload + Zout). On 6 Ω it loses 1.94 dB and on 4.9 Ω it loses 2.32 dB: the frequency response partially follows the loudspeaker's impedance curve (0.38 dB difference between the two points). That is why measuring the P52's Zout is the absolute priority.
Zout thresholds used in this report. The report works with two different criteria:
- Absolute loss on Zmin ≤ 1 dB: requires Zout ≤ 0.60 Ω (exact calculation on Zmin = 4.9 Ω: with 0.60 Ω the loss is 1.01 dB; with 0.50 Ω it is 0.84 dB). The report adopts 0.5 Ω as the recommended design target, not as an exact equivalent.
- Relative variation between Zmin and Zmax ≤ 1 dB: depends on Zmax (the impedance peak of the enclosure in the bass). Without measuring Zmax, the threshold is not reproducible. Reference table for Zmin = 4.9 Ω:
| Zmax (Ω) | Zout max. (Ω) for Δ ≤ 1 dB relative |
|---|---|
| 10 | 1.33 |
| 12 | 1.10 |
| 14 | 0.98 |
| 16.5 | 0.90 |
| 20 | 0.82 |
| 30 | 0.73 |
The report adopts Zout ≤ 0.9 Ω as the minimum working threshold, corresponding to Zmax ≈ 16.5 Ω. That value is a working reference, not a measurement of the owner's enclosure.
- No measurements of the P52 have been published. It looks like a careful build, but that does not mean good performance: B+, bias, feedback, Zout and P@1 % are still unproven.
- The weight (≈ 40 kg) suggests larger transformers, but it is not proof of quality or power, and it is also unverified.
- Neither a photograph nor a table can decide whether the amplifier "is better": that requires measurements (THD+N vs power, Zout, response into a real load, noise). These are proposed in the Appendix.
Exercises to practise:
- A loudspeaker has 92 dB/W/m. What level does it produce with 1 W at 2 m?
- With the 89 dB/W/m loudspeaker in this guide, what power is needed for 100 dB peak at 3 m with a single loudspeaker?
- A filter has 2000 µF and the amplifier draws 300 mA. What is the ripple at 100 Hz?
Show solutions
- 92 − 20·log₁₀(2) = 92 − 6.02 ≈ 86 dB.
- 10^((100 − 79.46)/10) ≈ 113 W.
- 0.3 / (100 · 0.002) = 1.5 V.
PART I — ACRONOS P52 REPORT
Map of what we know. From the general to the specific: architecture → boards → power stage → AC input → synthesis. Evidence levels are declared in §1 and applied in each section.
0. Executive summary
20-second read
What it is: an ultralinear push-pull valve amplifier with two 6550 valves per channel and 40 W nominal. At the input it has a 6Ж32П (equivalent to the EF86) and an ECC803S (dual triode). Most likely they amplify the signal and invert the phase to drive the two 6550s PROBABLE; the exact inverter scheme is ND until the board is traced. The transformers are varnished EI laminations mounted in a chassis with a metal partition OBSERVED. New to the terms? Start with the basic guide.
What has been identified in the photos: three EPCOS/TDK B43645 electrolytics, with 610 µF legible on at least one OBS (1,830 µF total CONDITIONAL CALCULATION if all three were 610 µF and wired in parallel); a vertical board (PCB-3) with 4 blue components OBS, probably relays PROB, of ND function; a 10W10KJ resistor rated 10 kΩ / 10 W OBS; two blue trimmers (adjustment potentiometers) on the signal board PCB-S, one at each end; and 16 yellow bodies (11 large and 5 small), 2 gold-coloured and 2 green bodies on the signal board in photograph 2.jpg OBS.
Identified with less certainty: the Hongfa HF115F relay PROB, the NE5532 op-amp PROB and the TL431 voltage reference PROB. For the NE555 timer there is no confirmation ND. There are two 8-pin (DIP-8) chips visible on the power-supply board PCB-P. Two toroids of 0.2–0.6 mH (Rev.A board, visual estimate) do not appear in the unit currently photographed.
What is NOT demonstrated: the actual B+ voltage (the valve supply), the effective capacitance of the capacitor bank, the bias mode of the 6550s (how their quiescent current is set), the global negative feedback (NFB), the %UL, the 1 % distortion power (P@1 %), the output impedance (Zout) or the damping factor (DF). Neither is it known what the blue trimmers, the 10W10KJ resistor or PCB-3 are for, where the low voltage for the NE5532 would come from (if confirmed) or what the start-up timing circuit is like.
Probable topological lineage: the P52 follows the same valve family as the Mullard 5-20 (design c. 1956, published in 1959), doubled to stereo and with solid-state rectification. Confirmation requires a manufacturer schematic or measurements (§3.2). "Probable lineage" is not "replica".
General description
The Acronos P52 is an ultralinear push-pull stereo amplifier rated 40 W nominal, with 6550 valves in the power stage. In the interior photographs at least three boards can be distinguished: the main signal board (PCB-S), very densely populated; the power-supply and control board (PCB-P), located at the back; and an independent vertical board (PCB-3) with four blue components, probably relays. In the rear-right corner there is also an auxiliary magnetic element of unknown function and a longitudinal metal partition separating the power and control area from the signal area.
Provisional conclusion
The design looks more elaborate than a minimal valve schematic, especially in the control and auxiliary-supply section, which is more complex than it appears at first glance. But none of the data that most affects real behaviour (B+, 6550 bias, NFB, %UL, Zout, P@1 %) is demonstrated. That is why the report remains a provisional reverse-engineering exercise: it describes what is visible and clearly flags what still has to be measured.
1. Scope, method and limitations
1.1 Source of evidence
- Visual inspection of photographs from the manufacturer's video: Amplificador ACRONOS P52 Una obra de arte. Cómo se fabricó.
- Additional interior photographs (2026-10) provided by the unit's owner. They allow reading the silkscreen of the three EPCOS B43645 capacitors, identifying the Hongfa HF115F relay and confirming the blue Bourns trimmers on PCB-S. They also show the vertical PCB-3, the auxiliary magnetic element and the longitudinal metal partition.
- Comparison with manufacturer catalogues: TDK/EPCOS, Bourns, TI (TL431, NE5532), JJ Electronic (valves), Hongfa, Schaffner, Würth, TAD (ECC803S), Mullard (5-20, EF86, EL34, ECC83), Genalex/New Sensor (KT77, KT88), RCA/GE (6SN7, 6CG7, 12BH7, 5687).
- Owner's reference system (the loudspeaker used for listening): Crossover A v2.4 MR-A-01 (6 Ω nom / Zmin 4.9 Ω / 89 dB/W/m), listening at 3 m.
1.2 Catalogue context — JC Valvular range
To place the P52 in context, the table lists the manufacturer's models and their topology (how the circuit is arranged):
| Model | Topology | Declared power | Category |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acronos M1 / RS-1 | Pure single-ended Class A (KT120/KT150) | 18–20 W | Pure valve, low power |
| Acronos P52 | Pure-valve push-pull ultralinear (4× 6550) | 40 W nominal | Pure valve, medium power. Manufacturer's ceiling in pure-valve topology |
| Acronos M2 | Hybrid (valve preamp + transistor output stage) | 60 W (field datum, 2026-10) | Hybrid, high power, high native DF without dependence on the output transformer |
1.3 Role glossary
| Role | Who | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Reviewer | Report author (maty @nauscopio) | Reference system, calculations, report structure |
| Owner of the reference system | Owner of the Crossover A v2.4 MR-A-01 | Sensitivity, Zmin and listening-condition data (89 dB/W/m, 3 m) |
| Owner of the P52 unit | Person with physical access to an Acronos P52 | Additional interior photographs (2026-10) that reveal PCB-3, the auxiliary magnetic element and the metal partition |
| Manufacturer | JC Valvular (Juan Calatayud) | Manufacturing video, 40 W commercial datasheet, design and components |
| Weight informant | Blog reader | Personal communication: P52 ≈ 40 kg, unverified |
2. General architecture — overview
2.1 Provisional physical architecture
The interior photographs allow us to sketch how the P52 is organised inside: at least three boards and a metal partition separating two zones. The diagram below is a location map, not an electrical circuit.
P52 (provisional physical architecture)
│
┌───────────────────────┴───────────────────────┐
│ │
POWER / HV ZONE CONTROL / AUXILIARY ZONE
│ │
PCB-P PCB-3 (vertical)
│ │
KBU1010 · C-HV EPCOS ×3 4 blue components
relays · 10W10KJ power resistor probably relays
TO-220 semiconductors function ND
MOSFET + TL431 block (PROB)
two DIP-8 (function ND)
│ │
└───────────────────────┬───────────────────────┘
│
PCB-S (front)
high density of passive components
and semiconductors · per-block function ND
│
valve stages
│
OPT · speaker output
Longitudinal metal partition physically separates both zones.
Auxiliary magnetic element in the rear-right corner (function ND).
Twisted wiring bundled in several runs.
PROVISIONAL PHYSICAL ARCHITECTURE DIAGRAM.
It does not represent a traced electrical schematic.
2.2 Functional block diagram with evidence levels
MAINS 230 V
│
+-- [EMI cap. obs.], NTC, RF-EMI filter (no L/N choke identified)
│
+-- Main supply transformer
│
↓
RECT KBU1010
│
↓
C HV EPCOS B43645 ×3 observed; 610 µF legible on at least one
1,830 µF CONDITIONAL CALCULATION if in parallel
Lifetime >5,000 h @ 105 °C (TDK, REPORTED-EXT)
│
↓
L1 toroidal Rev.A --- FUNCTION ND (absent in the currently photographed unit)
│
↓
C / HV branch --- PROBABLE
+-------------------+
│ │
power auxiliary
6550 / OPT MOSFET + TL431 (PROB)
blue Bourns
FUNCTION ND
(application not traced)
10W10KJ (10 kΩ / 10 W) --- OBSERVED
Not compatible with a permanent B+ bleeder at 430 V under that hypothesis.
Function ND: bridged inrush limiter, auxiliary bleeder, divider or load.
Hongfa HF115F relay --- PROBABLE (probable soft-start/inrush)
Auxiliary Songle/Finder relays --- PROBABLE
Vertical PCB-3 with 4 blue components --- BOARD OBSERVED
4 components --- PROBABLE relays · FUNCTION ND
NE5532 --- PROBABLE (function ND). Two DIP-8 visible.
NE555 --- ND / pending visual confirmation
Auxiliary magnetic element (rear-right corner) --- ND
Open hypotheses: auxiliary transformer, mains module, other.
Longitudinal metal partition --- OBSERVED
EMI/isolation intent --- PROBABLE
Actual effectiveness --- ND
Blue Bourns trimmers on PCB-S --- TWO OBSERVED, one at each end
Total number and function ND. Favours one per channel over four bias trimmers.
6550 without a trimmer clearly associated on PCB-S --- OBSERVED
Exact bias mode, quartet matching --- ND
OPERATING CLASS: AB probable (subtypes A, AB1, AB2 not observed)
AB1 is the reading most consistent with the observed topology (§5.2).
Indirect argument; without a schematic the subtype cannot be closed.
2.3 Overall topology
The Acronos P52 is an ultralinear push-pull stereo amplifier: two 6550 valves per channel and 40 W nominal per channel. The input stage (small signal) uses a 6Ж32П (EF86), a pentode, and an ECC803S (dual triode from JJ Electronic) for gain and phase inversion. The chassis holds three varnished EI transformers, with a metal partition between the supply and PCB-S OBSERVED. The valve combination is functionally reminiscent of the Mullard 5-20 (1959, design c. 1956), doubled to stereo and with the substitution of EL34 by 6550 (§3.2).
2.4 Functional blocks
| Block | Content | Section | Overall status |
|---|---|---|---|
| AC input and RF/EMI | Capacitors after the IEC inlet, NTC, PE, no L/N choke identified | §6 | PROBABLE general structure; X/Y class ND |
| PCB-P — Power supply and control | KBU1010, EPCOS B43645 HV, 10W10KJ, MOSFET + TL431 block (PROB), Hongfa relay (PROB), auxiliary relays, blue and black Bourns, two DIP-8 (NE5532 PROB, second ND) | §4 | PROBABLE by component; exact functions ND |
| PCB-S — Small signal | EF86, ECC803S, 16 yellow bodies (11 large and 5 small), 2 gold-coloured and 2 green bodies on the signal board in photograph 2.jpg, two visible blue Bourns 3296Y trimmers, precision resistors, signal diodes | §3 | PROBABLE layout; per-block function ND |
| PCB-3 — Independent vertical | 4 blue components, probably relays + transistors/diodes + electrolytics + resistors + wiring | §4.7 | BOARD OBSERVED · PROBABLE relays · ND function |
| Power stage | 4× 6550, EI OPT, bias | §5 | Class AB probable · AB1 subtype probable (§5.2). Bias mode, NFB, %UL ND |
2.5 What determines real behaviour and why it remains unknown (ND)
These are the data that would decide how the P52 sounds and behaves. None can be deduced from photographs alone:
- Actual B+ voltage and its behaviour under load.
- Bias mode of the 6550s: how their quiescent current is set.
- Operating subclass within AB (AB1 or AB2). It is an indirect inference, not an observed datum.
- Global negative feedback (NFB): whether it exists and how much (it returns part of the output to the input to reduce distortion).
- Ultralinear percentage (%UL): at what point of the output transformer (OPT) the taps are taken.
- P@1 % (power at 1 % distortion) and distortion-vs-power curve (THD+N).
- Zout (output impedance) and damping factor (DF): how much control the amplifier has over the loudspeaker.
- Effective capacitance of the HV bank.
- Matching of the 6550 quartet (that all four valves are similar).
- B+ supply architecture: number and separation of branches (§4.6).
- Exact function of the blue trimmers on PCB-S: total number, purpose and adjustment method.
- Exact function of the 10W10KJ: not compatible with a permanent B+ bleeder at 430 V under that hypothesis; other alternatives remain open (§4.3).
- Function of PCB-3 and of its four blue components (§4.7).
- Origin of the low-voltage rail for the control electronics (if the NE5532 is confirmed).
- Topology of the start-up timing circuit (specific component ND).
- Driver dynamic reserve: whether the ECC803S delivers sufficient voltage and current margin to the 6550 grids under the worst conditions (high band, maximum swing). This is something to verify, not an established defect (§3.3).
3. Small-signal board (PCB-S)
3.1 Observed components
PCB-S is an FR4 board by JC Valvular. It has four noval holes (9-pin valve sockets) for the EF86 and the two ECC803S triodes, and a fifth circular hole at the right end, with no apparent socket (function ND). Photograph 2.jpg shows 16 yellow bodies (11 large and 5 small), 2 gold-coloured and 2 green bodies on the signal board in photograph 2.jpg. CEC C2N markings are legible on several yellow components; colour does not establish dielectric or function. No snubber function is assigned without tracing the connections. The resistors are green MOX 10K28 2 W and white 1 W types. Two blue Bourns 3296Y trimmers (100 ppm/°C, 25 turns) are visible, one at each end; their total number and electrical function are ND.
Photograph-specific count. Photograph 2.jpg shows 16 yellow bodies (11 large and 5 small), 2 gold-coloured and 2 green bodies on the signal board in photograph 2.jpg. This count applies only to that board and photograph; it excludes the power-supply board and does not establish other hardware revisions. A perpendicular view would help confirm markings and hidden components.
Note on the CEC C2N capacitors. There are many film capacitors distributed symmetrically. They may serve several purposes: interstage coupling, signal bypass, local decoupling, compensation, snubbing or frequency-shaping networks. Assigning each C2N to a specific function without tracing the board would be a methodological error.
The large number of components and the symmetric layout of the two channels are OBSERVED and consistent with a careful build. No trimmer is clearly associated with an individual 6550 in the photos, so bias remains unresolved (§3.4).
3.2 Probable topology and Mullard 5-20 lineage
The ECC803S is a dual triode (A.F. twin triode from JJ Electronic): two independent triodes in a single noval envelope. With one EF86 and one ECC803S per channel, there are three common ways to arrange them:
- EF86 (input) → ECC803S as LTP (long-tailed pair) with both triodes. This is the classic combination: the EF86 provides voltage gain and the ECC803S pair inverts the phase with high gain. MAIN HYPOTHESIS, not observed in the photos.
- EF86 (input) → one ECC803S triode as gain stage → the other as cathodyne or driver (simple phase inverter). ALTERNATIVE HYPOTHESIS.
- EF86 (input) → one ECC803S triode as gain stage → the other as asymmetric driver. This is unusual. MINOR HYPOTHESIS.
Probable reading (common to the three hypotheses):
RCA → EF86 (pentode, Ra 100 kΩ)
→ C → ECC803S (dual triode)
[hypothesis 1: LTP with both triodes]
[hypothesis 2: gain + cathodyne/driver]
[hypothesis 3: gain + asymmetric driver]
→ 2× C → 6550 grids
Gain budget (estimate, not measurement). Suppose 1 Vrms at the input reaches maximum power, and that the 6550 grids need about 30–50 Vpeak (≈21–35 Vrms). The total gain needed would be 21–35×, that is, 26.5–31.0 dB. That fits an EF86 (typical stage gain ≈100–150×, see note) followed by an ECC803S LTP (≈10–20×), with global feedback reducing the final gain. The calculation is compatible with hypothesis 1 (EF86 → LTP), but it does not prove it. PROBABLE.
Note on EF86 gain. A pentode does not have a μ comparable to a triode's: its true μ (gm × ra) would be of the order of thousands. The "185" figure in the literature is the maximum stage gain — gm (1.85 mA/V) times the plate load (≈100 kΩ) — not a datasheet parameter. The actual stage gain in a given design is lower (typically 100–150), because the effective plate load is reduced by the internal resistance and by the loading of the following stage. When this report quotes "≈100–200× gain" for the EF86, it refers to that stage order of magnitude, not to a catalogue μ.
What is the Mullard 5-20?
The Mullard 5-20 is a reference push-pull amplifier design published by Mullard Ltd in its booklet "Circuits for Audio Amplifiers" (the design circulates since c. 1956; revised edition 1959, reprinted 1962). The name is descriptive: 5 valves (EF86, ECC83, 2× EL34, GZ34) and 20 watts output. The 5-20 documentation went through several revisions; "Mullard 5-20" should not be treated as a single, unchanging schematic.
It was the reference amplifier of the British high-fidelity school in the 1950s. It served as a template for many later commercial amplifiers and influenced the British school that included Leak, Rogers and Radford. It became the canonical pattern of the British push-pull.
Mullard 5-20 → Acronos P52 correspondence
| Stage | Mullard 5-20 (original, mono) | Acronos P52 (observed, stereo) | Correspondence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Input | 1× EF86 (low-noise pentode) | 2× EF86 / 6Ж32П (one per channel) | Functionally identical |
| Driver / inverter | 1× ECC83 (dual triode, μ ≈ 100) | 2× ECC803S (one per channel) | Functional equivalent (ECC803S is a long-plate variant of the ECC83 family) |
| Power | 2× EL34 in push-pull class AB1 | 4× 6550 (2 per channel) | Similar topology, different valve |
| Rectification | 1× GZ34 (valve) | KBU1010 (solid-state) OBSERVED | Different (solid-state rectification) |
| Feedback | Global NFB — see note | ND (not measured) | No automatic transfer to the P52 |
| Configuration | Mono | Stereo | Doubled |
| Nominal power | 20 W into 7.5–15 Ω | 40 W per channel DECLARED by the manufacturer | Doubling to stereo does not imply 40 W per channel: that depends on the valves, the supply, the biasing and the transformers |
| THD at 20 W | ≈ 0.1 % at 1 kHz (Mullard, Circuits for Audio Amplifiers, 1959) | ND | — |
| B+ | ≈ 400 V for EL34 | ND | Probably higher for 6550 |
- It reinforces the AB1 inference. The Mullard 5-20 operated in AB1. If the P52 follows a similar scheme, it is coherent that it also does, although it cannot be asserted with certainty.
- It explains why there is no cathode follower or interstage transformer. The 5-20 does not use them; nor does the P52. Both are consistent with the British school of the period.
- It explains the EF86 choice. It is not arbitrary: it is the input valve of the reference design.
- It explains the ECC803S choice. It is the premium variant of the 5-20's ECC83, available today as a high-end option.
Indicative model — not a P52 extrapolation. The following table relates global NFB depth to typical orders of magnitude of Zout and DF, as a pedagogical reference. Actual values depend on open-loop Zout, frequency, transformer, load, stability and phase. It does not allow estimating the P52's Zout from an assumed NFB.
| Configuration (indicative) | Typical Zout (order of magnitude) | Typical DF on 6 Ω |
|---|---|---|
| No global NFB | 2 to 4 Ω | ≈ 1.5 – 3 |
| 6 dB global NFB | 1 to 2 Ω (÷2) | ≈ 3 – 6 |
| 12 dB global NFB | 0.5 to 1 Ω (÷4) | ≈ 6 – 12 |
| 20 dB global NFB | 0.2 to 0.4 Ω (÷10) | ≈ 15 – 30 |
| Hypothesis | How it works | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Two trimmers, one per channel (signal-stage adjustment or DC balance of the inverter) | Two blue trimmers, one at each end of PCB-S, adjust the symmetry of each channel. | FAVOURED BY THE CURRENT OBSERVATION — two trimmers visible, one at each end |
| Individual bias with 4 trimmers | Four trimmers individually adjust the bias of each 6550. Two could be on the underside. | HYPOTHESIS — not ruled out; requires underside inspection |
| Fixed polarisation by resistive divider | Negative voltage fixed by a resistive divider (the blue trimmers would have another function). | PROBABLE; mode ND. |
| Cathode bias | Power cathode resistors with bypass. | ND — not identified. |
| Bias from auxiliary block | Adjustment from PCB-P (MOSFET + TL431 + blue Bourns). | HYPOTHESIS — requires tracing. |
3.3 ECC803S driver: current capability to be verified
The ECC803S is a voltage-gain valve (μ = 100, Ri = 62.5 kΩ). That nature is a catalogue datum, not a limitation. What should be made clear is that a voltage valve is not the same as a current valve, and that the question "does the ECC803S deliver enough current to the 6550 grids?" cannot be answered from photographs. This section orders why the question matters, what can be estimated and what cannot be concluded.
Why driver current may matter
Charging the input capacitance of a power valve requires current. The peak current needed to charge a capacitance C at a frequency f with a peak voltage V is:
With C ≈ 100 pF (conservative hypothesis: includes Miller effect, grid capacitance and parasitics), f = 20 kHz and V = 20 V peak: Ipeak ≈ 0.25 mA. This is a peak, instantaneous figure, not a DC current.
The JJ 6550 datasheets circulating among distributors give noticeably lower capacitances: of the order of 14 pF grid and 0.85 pF grid-plate. The Miller effect multiplies the latter by the gain of the power stage, and the resulting value depends on the operating point. The 100 pF figure used here is an order-of-magnitude ceiling, not a P52 measurement.
If the P52 operates in AB1 — the most consistent with the observed topology (§5.2) — the control grid does not enter positive conduction, and there is no DC grid current. The driver only has to deliver voltage and a small peak current to charge parasitic capacitances. In that scenario, the question of whether the ECC803S is "sufficient" is a matter of margin, not of insufficiency.
Current capability comparison
| Valve | μ | Ri | Icat, max (datasheet) | Socket | Natural role |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ECC803S (current) | 100 | 62.5 kΩ | 8 mA (TAD) | Noval (9-pin) | Voltage gain |
| 12AX7 / ECC83 | 100 | 62.5 kΩ | 8–9 mA | Noval | Voltage gain |
| 12AT7 / ECC81 | 60 | ~15 kΩ | ~20 mA | Noval | Moderate-gain driver |
| 12AU7 / ECC82 | 20 | ~7.7 kΩ | ~20 mA | Noval | Current driver |
| 6SN7 | 20 | ~7.7 kΩ | 20 mA | Octal (8-pin) | Robust driver, excellent linearity |
| 6CG7 | 20 | ~7.7 kΩ | 20 mA | Noval (9-pin) | Identical to 6SN7 in noval format |
| 12BH7 | 17 | ~7 kΩ | ~30 mA | Noval | Highest-current noval driver |
| 5687 | 17 | ~1 kΩ | ~35 mA | Noval (different pinout) | Minimum impedance |
- The ECC803S is the element whose current-delivery capability deserves verification if the driver's dynamic reserve is to be evaluated.
- It cannot be identified as a performance limitation without measuring signal swing, high-frequency distortion, response into a complex load and grid current.
- If the characterisation showed an anomalous THD increase with frequency or an inability to maintain the required swing, then it would make sense to study lower-impedance drivers (§3.5).
3.4 Probable function of the PCB-S blue Bourns trimmers
Two blue Bourns 3296Y trimmers (100 ppm/°C, 25 turns, 0.5 W) are visible, one at each end of the board, which is consistent with one per channel. What exactly they adjust (the signal stage, the DC balance of the phase inverter or something else) remains ND without tracing the board. If there were another two on the underside, individual per-valve bias would again become possible.
3.5 Driver substitutions — proposal pending measurement
If characterisation showed a real driver limitation — for example, an anomalous THD increase with frequency, an inability to maintain the required swing into a complex load, or unstable behaviour under NFB — then it would make sense to study lower-impedance, higher-current-capability valves. This section catalogues the candidates and the technical conditions for that evaluation, should it arise, to be orderly.
Technical conditions to verify before any substitution
- Socket and pinout compatibility. The ECC803S is a 12AX7 variant: noval socket with dual heater (pins 4/5/9). The 12AT7, 12AU7 and 12BH7 share that pinout and heater configuration: they fit physically without adaptation. The real risk is not in the pins but in the operating point (bias, cathode resistor and plate load will be displaced). The 6CG7 matches the signal pins but uses a single 6.3 V heater between pins 4 and 5 with a screen on pin 9: in a socket wired for 12AX7 it will not receive heater power and needs rewiring. The 6SN7 (octal) and the 5687 (noval with a different pinout) require socket adaptation.
- Total loop gain. Moving from an ECC803S (μ = 100) to a 6SN7 (μ = 20) or a 12BH7 (μ = 17) reduces stage gain by about 14.0 to 15.4 dB. The input EF86 (typical stage gain 100–150×) would largely compensate for that loss, but if the P52 uses global NFB, that NFB might need readjustment.
- Operating point. Each valve has a different transconductance curve. The change alters quiescent current, plate dissipation and the symmetry of the push-pull pair. In the P52, with two visible trimmers, it is probably possible to readjust bias, but the adjustment range is ND.
- Subsequent verification. Square wave at 1 kHz and 10 kHz, response at 20 kHz into a complex load, THD+N vs power, stability under NFB.
Candidates ordered by practical suitability
| Candidate | Type | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 6CG7 | The most balanced | Electrically identical to the 6SN7 but in noval format. Requires verifying the heater wiring (single 6.3 V vs dual 12AX7). Used by Conrad-Johnson Premier Eleven. |
| 6SN7 | Technical reference | Excellent linearity and mechanical robustness. Requires a socket adapter (noval → octal). |
| 12BH7 | Maximum performance in noval | ~30 mA available. 12AX7-compatible pinout. Used by VTL S-200 (with 6550). Requires bias readjustment and heater-consumption verification. |
| 5687 | Minimum impedance | ~1 kΩ. The best for handling parasitic capacitances. Noval pinout different from the 12AX7. Used by Sonic Frontiers Power 2 (8× 6550). |
| 12AU7 / ECC82 | Intermediate | ~20 mA, 12AX7-compatible pinout. μ = 20. Requires verifying the remaining gain with the EF86. |
Conservative alternatives (same socket, no topology change)
If the driver quality were to be improved without changing families, there are long-plate 12AX7 alternatives:
- TAD ECC803S Premium Selected — long plate, premium selection with noise, microphony and shock tests.
- Mullard Reissue 12AX7 — long plate, warm and three-dimensional profile.
- Sovtek 12AX7LPS — long plate, spiral heater to reduce hum.
- Genalex Gold Lion 12AX7 — gold-plated pins, very low microphony.
These valves do not increase the driver's current capability (they are still 12AX7). They may offer improvements in noise, microphony and consistency without altering the topology or the socket, but the character descriptions ("warm", "crystal-clear") come from audiophile folklore, not from measurements; they are quoted only as commercial guidance.
3.6 Cross-reference
The bias mode is covered in §3.2 and §5.3. The trimmers are catalogued in §4.5 and in Part II §7. The B+ supply is in §4.6 and PCB-3 in §4.7. The operating class is developed in §5.2. Driver substitutions are in §3.5 (proposal pending measurement).
PCB-S images
4. Power supply and control board (PCB-P)
On PCB-P the following are clearly visible: the KBU1010 rectifier (10 A), input MKP capacitors, the 10W10KJ resistor, three large EPCOS/TDK B43645 (silkscreen B43645-S7617-M1 partly legible), a 100 µF / 450 V capacitor and TO-220 heatsinks. With less certainty, a regulation/control block with a TL431 PROB and its trimmer are identified, plus the Hongfa HF115F relay PROB and auxiliary Songle and Finder relays (function ND). There are also two DIP-8 chips whose marking cannot be read in the photos: one could be a NE5532 PROB and the other is ND. The NE555 is not confirmed.
The photos also show diodes and transistors on the right-hand side, an encapsulated magnetic element in the rear-right corner (function ND, see §4.7), several auxiliary electrolytics in blue and black distributed across the board, and a fuse holder next to the mains inlet. On the rear wall there are gold-plated terminals with nuts and blue, red and green twisted wiring; they could be speaker outputs or inputs, but their function is ND.
Three EPCOS/TDK capacitors in photo 2.jpg. At least one reads 610 µF. Ratings of the other parts, identity with the assembled unit and wiring: ND.
Partial readings of the markings on the high-voltage bank:
The three electrolytics are together, forming a single HV bank on PCB-P. That supports the idea that they are connected in parallel, but does not prove it: tracing the tracks on the underside is needed to confirm it.
Epistemic chain on the HV bank — separation of levels
| Claim | Status |
|---|---|
| Three HV electrolytics physically grouped forming a bank | OBSERVED |
| Code B43645-S7617-M1 pending confirmation on all three parts | OBSERVED on the silkscreen |
| 610 µF legible on at least one part. Voltage ratings and full markings: ND | OBSERVED on the silkscreen |
| Exact correspondence of the code with the TDK datasheet (ordering code table) | PENDING VERIFICATION — not yet cross-checked against the full ordering code |
| Series identified as B43645 (not the related B43655 family) | PROBABLE from the visible code · requires confirmation |
| Parallel connection of the three | PROBABLE — simplest reading, consistent with a grouped bank · ND without tracing |
| 1,830 µF effective | CONDITIONAL CALCULATION if all three capacitors are 610 µF and connected in parallel |
| Actual equivalent capacitance of the bank | ND until the solder side is inspected |
| Nominal lifetime >5,000 h at 105 °C | Datum for the B43645 series per TDK documentation REPORTED-EXT — not measured on this unit |
| Illustrative scenario at 65 °C (hypothesis) | ≈ 80,000 h CALCULATED from 5,000 h at 105 °C using the doubling rule for every 10 °C decrease |
| Illustrative scenario at 55 °C (hypothesis) | ≈ 160,000 h CALCULATED from 5,000 h at 105 °C using the doubling rule for every 10 °C decrease |
- The nominal lifetime of the B43645 series according to current TDK documentation is >5,000 h at 105 °C. TDK identifies the 8,000 h series as different families.
- TDK has closely related families B43645 and B43655 with non-identical specifications. Until the full inscription is confirmed against the ordering-code table, the exact identification of the P52 component must be classified as PROBABLE, not CONFIRMED.
- The 80,000 h at 65 °C and 160,000 h at 55 °C figures illustrate a rule of thumb applied to the series specification. Service life in this unit remains undetermined until the exact part number, operating temperature and ripple current are verified.
- Factors that prevent a closed quantitative comparison with other capacitors: the actual internal temperature of the chassis, the effective ripple current and the quality of the exact series. None is measurable with current evidence.
Rev.A (earlier board revision): two brown copper toroids, 15 mm, with fine wire 0.3–0.5 mm (2 wires each), in series between the KBU1010 and the EPCOS bank. Rev.B (the board revision in the currently photographed unit): those toroids are no longer present in their historical position. They are not filament transformers nor a 1 H choke.
| Revision / element | Observed | Value / function | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rev.A toroids | 2× copper 15 mm in series KBU1010→EPCOS (in historical images) | Toroidal magnetic element. L, DCR, I_sat and function ND. | OBSERVED in Rev.A · value ND |
| Rev.B (current unit) | Toroids not observed in their historical position | Absence confirmed in the photographed unit | OBSERVED |
| 10W10KJ | Silkscreen 10W10KJ | 10 kΩ / 10 W. Not compatible with a permanent B+ bleeder at 430 V. Exact function ND. | OBSERVED the value · ND the function |
| PCB-P blue element | Blue Bourns + blue electrolytics + SONGLE SRD | Negative-bias relay (hypothesis) | OBSERVED the components · ND the exact function |
- Direct calculation: with B+ = 430 V, the permanent dissipation from B+ to ground would be P = V² / R = 430² / 10,000 ≈ 18.5 W, above its 10 W rating. Maximum continuous voltage permissible for 10 W into 10 kΩ: V_max = √(10·10,000) ≈ 316 V.
- Logical closure: if it were directly subjected to 430 V permanently, it would dissipate ≈18.5 W against a 10 W rating. That configuration does not look compatible with continuous operation at 430 V under that hypothesis.
- Quiescent current if in the B+ line: I = 430 / 10,000 = 43 mA.
- That the 10W10KJ is a pre-charge resistor. That is PROBABLE, not proven.
- That the bank it acts on is 1,830 µF.
- That the relay switches at the end of the complete bank's RC transient.
- That there is a dominant time constant τ = R·C. If the above hypotheses held, τ = 10,000 · 1.83·10⁻³ ≈ 18.3 s, but that calculation is conditional.
- That the resistor actually sees 430 V. If it operates on an auxiliary branch at 200–300 V, it would dissipate 4–9 W and be within its rating.
- Inrush limiter bridged by the Hongfa relay.
- Bleeder of the regulated auxiliary branch (if that branch operates at 200–300 V, it would dissipate 4–9 W, within rating).
- Voltage divider or regulator load.
- Another function not considered.
On PCB-P there are TO-220 heatsinks, a TL431 PROB, associated blue Bourns trimmers and auxiliary electrolytics. This set fits several possible functions:
- Regulating the negative bias voltage of the 6550s.
- Providing an auxiliary low-voltage supply (Vaux) to the control electronics.
- Monitoring and protecting (comparing thresholds, detecting overcurrent or DC offset at the output).
- Providing a voltage reference to another circuit.
| Colour / position | Temp. coefficient | Probable function | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blue (PCB-S) | 100 ppm/°C | One per channel: small-signal stage adjustment or DC balance of the inverter. If there were another two on the underside, they could be individual 6550 bias. | OBSERVED two, one at each end · total number and function ND |
| Blue (PCB-P) | 100 ppm/°C | Auxiliary regulation/control block (with MOSFET + TL431); exact application ND | PROBABLE |
| Black (PCB-P) | ND | Possible threshold/timing or other control function | HYPOTHESIS |
4.6.1 The question
In a 40 W push-pull, the four 6550s draw a current that varies with the music, and those variations make the B+ rail voltage fluctuate. If that fluctuation reaches the small-signal stages, it produces intermodulation and unwanted coupling. A classic technique to avoid it is to split B+ into branches.
This question (how B+ is distributed) is independent of the control and auxiliary circuits question (§4.7). The existence of a relay board or an auxiliary magnetic element does not say whether B+ goes in one branch or several, nor vice versa.
4.6.2 The three possible architectures
(a) BRANCHES WITH SERIES R OR L
Main B+
├── POWER B+ ──► 6550
├── R1 + C3 ──► DRIVER B+ (ECC803S)
└── R2 + C4 ──► INPUT B+ (EF86)
(b) SINGLE RAIL WITH LOCAL BYPASS
Main B+ ──► all valves, no series R or L
with local C next to each socket
(c) SINGLE RAIL WITHOUT LOCAL BYPASS
Main B+ ──► all valves, no local C
4.6.3 What is observed in the P52
| Evidence | What it suggests | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Common filter bank on PCB-P (three EPCOS B43645 with the same silkscreen, grouped) | Single main B+ rail or parallel banks per channel | OBSERVED |
| In the available photographs, no power resistors are observed in series with B+ taps on PCB-P | Probable absence of architecture (a) | OBSERVED constrained · inference PROBABLE |
| Two small electrolytic capacitors near the noval sockets on PCB-S | Most likely reading: cathode bypass, not rail decoupling | HYPOTHESIS — evidence neutral on branch separation |
| Presence of 10W10KJ (10 kΩ / 10 W) incompatible with a permanent bleeder of the main B+ at 430 V | Suggests an auxiliary branch or a start-up circuit, not the main B+ rail | OBSERVED the value · ND the function |
| Cable bundle between PCB-P and PCB-S | Wires cannot be counted nor route traced | ND |
4.6.4 The three architecture hypotheses
| Architecture | Description | Status |
|---|---|---|
| (a) Branches with series R or L | Power B+ → 6550; driver B+ → ECC803S with RC network; input B+ → EF86 with RC network. | HYPOTHESIS — not elevated by the numerical coincidence |
| (b) Single rail with local bypass | Single B+, with local capacitors next to the sockets (no series R or L). | PROBABLE — most conservative reading with current evidence |
| (c) Single rail without local bypass | Single B+, without local capacitors. | MINOR HYPOTHESIS |
4.6.5 B+ ripple in push-pull: cancellation in the OPT
In a push-pull stage, B+ ripple reaches the plates of the two output valves in phase, i.e. at the two ends of the output transformer (OPT) primary. The OPT largely rejects that common component. What matters is the ripple that reaches the driver and phase-inversion stages, because there it becomes a spurious signal that is amplified.
4.6.6 How the question would be resolved
- Photo of the underside of PCB-S (solder side).
- Photo of the B+ inlet connector/point on PCB-S.
- Count the Bourns trimmers on PCB-S (P14).
- Trace the 10W10KJ connection (P15).
- Voltage measurement at the B+ inlet to PCB-S and at the plate pins of the EF86 and ECC803S.
- Ripple measurement at each point with an oscilloscope.
4.7.1 The evidence
The general interior view shows at least three boards and a longitudinal metal partition between zones. The new elements are:
- PCB-3: independent vertical board in the rear-left corner, with four blue rectangular components in a row and associated electronics (transistors, diodes, electrolytics, resistors and connectors).
- Auxiliary magnetic element: encapsulated component in the rear-right corner, apart from the three main transformers and near the mains inlet and a fuse holder.
- Longitudinal metal partition between the power-supply/control zone and the signal and power zone.
4.7.2 Epistemic chain of PCB-3
| Claim | Status |
|---|---|
| An independent vertical board exists in the rear-left corner | OBSERVED |
| The board contains four aligned blue rectangular components | OBSERVED |
| The four components are electromechanical relays | PROBABLE — geometry and layout compatible, without reading markings |
| The board performs signal/input switching | HYPOTHESIS — compatible with its location next to the rear panel |
| The board performs mute or output protection | HYPOTHESIS alternative |
| The board performs power switching | HYPOTHESIS less likely |
| Concrete function of each component | ND |
4.7.3 On the metal partition
| Claim | Status |
|---|---|
| A longitudinal metal partition exists between zones | OBSERVED |
| The layout aims to reduce electromagnetic coupling and/or separate zones of different voltage/power | PROBABLE — deliberate construction decision |
| The partition is effective for EMI, ground return, residual magnetic field or crosstalk | NOT MEASURED |
4.7.4 On the auxiliary magnetic element
ND: its function. Open hypotheses, none confirmed:
- Auxiliary control transformer (would fit with the low-voltage rail the NE5532 would need, if confirmed).
- Mains inlet module or fuse holder (would fit with its location next to the mains inlet).
- Another magnetic or filtering component.
4.7.5 What it implies and what it does not
Implies:
- Describing the P52 interior as at least three boards, a metal partition and an auxiliary magnetic element of ND function.
- Assuming that control is more complex than a quick look suggested.
- Noting as a structural finding the deliberate separation between the power zone and the control and signal zone.
Does not imply:
- That B+ has more branches (a separate question, §4.6).
- That a relay input selector exists (HYPOTHESIS).
- That a relay-based protection system exists (HYPOTHESIS).
- That there is valve warm-up timing with a specific component (HYPOTHESIS).
- That the NE5532 detects DC offset at the output (HYPOTHESIS).
- That the auxiliary magnetic element is a transformer (ND).
5. Power stage
5.1 Valves and dissipation — 6550 vs KT88 vs EL34 vs KT77
Four 6550 valves are visible (two per channel), which in the manufacturer's video appear to be Tung-Sol. How much heat each plate dissipates in operation is ND: it would require measuring V_plate-cathode · I_cathode (voltage times current).
To place the P52's valve within its family, the table compares the fundamental electrical characteristics of the four most relevant octal-socket valves. Bold marks the limits that condition ultralinear (UL) operation.
| Characteristic | 6550 (P52) | KT88 | EL34 | KT77 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Beam tetrode | Beam tetrode | Pentode | Beam tetrode |
| Max plate dissipation | 35 W | 42 W | 25 W | 25 W (current Genalex; see note) |
| Max plate voltage | 600 V | 800 V | 800 V | ≤800 V (Genalex) / 600 V (alternative sources) |
| Max screen voltage (g2) | 400 V | 600 V | 425 V | ND |
| Heater current | 1.6 A | 1.6 A | 1.5 A | 1.5 A (approx.) |
5.2 Operating class: AB probable; AB1 subtype probable
The operating class (A, AB, B) describes how the work is distributed between the valves of a push-pull pair when there is no signal. It determines quiescent current, thermal dissipation and behaviour near clipping. Within class AB there are two subtypes: AB1 (the control grid never goes positive with respect to the cathode; the driver only delivers voltage) and AB2 (the grid goes positive at peaks and demands real current; requires a driver capable of delivering it).
P52 classification
For the P52, both the class and the subtype are indirect inferences. The most honest position is to leave both labels at PROBABLE.
| Aspect | Classification | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Class AB | PROBABLE | The visible topology (push-pull pair of 6550s, valve driver in class A, typical dissipation of 2 valves per channel) is consistent with AB. No explicit manufacturer data has been verified against the official P52 datasheet. |
| AB1 subtype | PROBABLE | Four convergent observations (see below). Consistent with the Mullard 5-20 lineage and with the absence of typical AB2 resources. |
| AB2 subtype | NOT RULED OUT | Requires schematic, voltages, polarisation, load impedances and driver-transformer data. Without these, it cannot be excluded by calculation. |
AB1 subtype argument (four convergent observations)
- The driver is an ECC803S, a voltage-gain valve (μ = 100, Ri = 62.5 kΩ). Its specified maximum cathode current is 8 mA (TAD datasheet), but that datum should not be interpreted as grid current available for AB2. It is a voltage valve, not a power valve.
- The typical resources of AB2 are not observed. A conventional AB2 implementation requires considerably more grid current delivery capability than is usual in a voltage ECC83/ECC803S stage. The photographs do not show an evident power driver stage: there are no additional valves beyond the 4× 6550 and the 4 preamp/driver valves; there is no interstage transformer (only the three large EI: supply and two outputs); the visible MOSFET/TL431 block is low-power and probably handles bias, not signal swing.
- The declared power (40 W per channel) fits AB1, not AB2. A push-pull with 2× 6550 per channel in AB1 delivers 40–60 W per channel depending on B+ and transformer. In AB2 with the same B+ one could reach 50–75 W. If the design were AB2, the implementation cost would be justified by an extra power that does not appear.
- Similarity with the Mullard 5-20. The historical reference design (1959, design c. 1956) operated in AB1 with a voltage driver (ECC83). If the P52 follows that line, it is coherent that it also operates in AB1 (see §3.2). This observation is an analogy, not direct evidence.
- That the ECC803S does not drive the 6550 directly but an intermediate stage that is not visible.
- That the MOSFET/TL431 block acts as a current buffer towards the grid.
- That there is a small interstage transformer camouflaged among the components.
5.3 Bias mode
Open hypotheses: two visible trimmers on PCB-S (one per channel), which might adjust the signal or the inverter's DC balance; individual bias with four trimmers, if there are two more on the underside; fixed polarisation by voltage divider; cathode polarisation; or bias from the auxiliary block. Full development in §3.2. The exact polarisation mode is ND. The operating class is classified as AB probable, AB1 subtype probable (§5.2).
5.4 6550 substitutions
The P52's octal socket admits, in principle, other valves of the same family: KT88, KT90 or KT120. Substitution is not automatic; two conditions must be verified before changing valves.
- Current reserve of the heater winding (6.3 V). The 6550 and KT88 draw 1.6 A per valve; the KT120 draws between 1.7 and 1.95 A depending on the manufacturer. Four KT120s would add up to 7.8 A in the power stage alone, plus the heaters of the four preamp/driver valves. If the EI transformer has no margin, the heater voltage will drop below 6.0 V and shorten the life of all valves (not just the substituted ones).
- Negative bias circuit headroom. A correctly biased KT120 requires more negative bias voltages than a 6550. If the bias circuit does not reach that value, the valve will operate outside its optimum point and may dissipate beyond its limits.
5.5 Open questions
| Parameter | Status | Section where it is covered |
|---|---|---|
| Operating class / subtype | AB PROBABLE; AB1 subtype PROBABLE; AB2 NOT RULED OUT without a schematic. | §5.2 |
| Global NFB | ND — the Mullard 5-20 figure is in conflict in the literature (20–26 dB vs ~30 dB) and does not transfer to the P52. Visual detection described in §3.2 | Appendix P6 |
| %UL | ND | Appendix P7 |
| Zout and DF | ND — NFB effect tabulated as an indicative model in §3.2 | Appendix P2 |
| P@1 % and THD+N vs power curve | ND | Appendix P1 |
| 6550 quartet matching | ND | Part II §8 |
| B+ architecture | HYPOTHESIS (a) · PROBABLE (b) single rail with local bypass | §4.6, Appendix P10 |
| Phase-inverter topology | HYPOTHESIS (EF86 → main LTP); Mullard 5-20 analogy as indirect argument; ND confirmation | §3.2 |
| ECC803S driver dynamic reserve | Element to verify. I_cat,max = 8 mA (TAD). Without measurement, a limitation cannot be asserted. Alternatives catalogued as proposal pending measurement: 6CG7, 6SN7, 12BH7, 5687. | §3.3, §3.5 |
| Function of the blue trimmers on PCB-S | TWO OBSERVED · total number and function ND | §3.4, §4.5, Appendix P14 |
| Function of the 10W10KJ | OBSERVED the value · ND the function (not compatible with a permanent B+ bleeder at 430 V) | §4.3, Appendix P15 |
| Function of PCB-3 | OBSERVED the board · ND the function | §4.7, Appendix P16 |
| Origin of the low-voltage rail | PROBABLE if NE5532 confirmed · ND origin | §4.4, Appendix P16 |
5.6 Output transformers
Three varnished EI transformers are visible (one for supply, two for output), with a metal partition between the supply and PCB-S OBSERVED. Primary impedance, turns ratio, leakage inductance and frequency response are ND.
5.7 Calculators — SPL and Zout variation
SPL and required power calculator — P52 40 W
Formulas: SPL_1W@d = sens − 20·log10(d) and P = 10^((SPL_target − SPL_1W@d − factor)/10). Results per channel.
Response variation calculator by Zout
6. AC input and RF/EMI — observed state
6.1 Observed state of the input filter
In the photos, capacitors of about 0.1 µF / 1000 V are visible just after the IEC connector (the mains inlet), consistent with an EMI (interference) filter. Their X/Y safety class has not been established, and no common-mode L/N choke is visible.
6.2 PE and chassis
The chassis appears to be connected directly to protective earth (PE) PROBABLE.
6.3 Y capacitors
They have not been identified with certainty. Their presence is PROBABLE by position, ND by tracing.
6.4 Soft-start and start-up sequence — open problem
- Whether the 10W10KJ is part of an HV bank pre-charge circuit.
- Which bank capacitors are in series with it.
- What circuit controls relay switching.
- How long between mains connection and relay switching.
- What component counts that time (NE555 ND, another IC ND, or an RC with comparator ND).
The calculation τ = R·C = 18.3 s is conditional: it assumes that the 10W10KJ is in series with the complete 1.83 mF bank and that the relay switches at the end of the RC transient. Neither is demonstrated. It is an open problem, not a resolved contradiction.
6.5 What this report does NOT propose to modify here
7. Conclusion and traceability
7.1 Acoustic model — conditional scenarios
The power needed to reach 95 dB depends on how the enclosure's sensitivity has been defined. Each row of the table starts from a different reference, and each result is coherent with its own. All values are conditional estimates, not P52 measurements.
| Reading / condition | Level at 3 m | Power for 95 dB | Margin over 40 W |
|---|---|---|---|
| 89 dB @ 1 W / 1 m; listening at 3 m, free field | ≈79.5 dB | ≈35.8 W | +0.5 dB |
| 89 dB @ 2.83 V / 1 m into 5.3 Ω (1.51 W); listening at 3 m, free field | ≈77.7 dB at 1 W | ≈54.1 W | −1.3 dB |
| 89 dB SPL with 1 W measured directly at 3 m | 89 dB | ≈4.0 W | +10.0 dB |
Calculation: power = 10^((95 − level per 1 W)/10) and margin = 10·log10(40/power). Row 2 uses the sensitivity referred to 1 W (77.7 dB at 3 m), which is the magnitude coherent with the rest of the calculation. Note: the table is mono and free-field. The three cases use the same reference (level at 3 m with 1 W applied), without mixing 1 W with 2.83 V. None of these scenarios demonstrates the P52's real performance.
7.2 Report synthesis
PCB-S shows a careful build, with many coupling and filter capacitors, two blue Bourns trimmers (one at each end) and precision blue resistors. In the supply there are three EPCOS/TDK electrolytics. In photo 2.jpg, 610 µF is legible on at least one. The voltage ratings and full codes of all three parts remain unconfirmed. The effective capacitance of the combination remains ND: the wiring admits at least four readings, and only the three-in-parallel one would give 1,830 µF. The nominal lifetime of the B43645 series is >5,000 h at 105 °C according to TDK, and the exact correspondence of the code to the datasheet remains PENDING VERIFICATION against the ordering-code table, because the B43645 and B43655 families are not identical.
The vertical PCB-3 with four blue components is OBSERVED; that they are relays is PROBABLE; its function is ND. The auxiliary magnetic element in the rear-right corner is OBSERVED as a physical component, but its function is ND: auxiliary transformer, mains inlet/fuse-holder module and other uses are open hypotheses.
The longitudinal metal partition is OBSERVED; the intent of EMI/isolation separation is PROBABLE; its actual effectiveness is ND.
The Hongfa HF115F relay is PROBABLE by position and geometry, compatible with soft-start/inrush. The two DIP-8s observed on PCB-P reinforce the presence of control electronics, but do not identify a specific component: NE5532 PROBABLE, NE555 ND.
The 10W10KJ resistor (10 kΩ / 10 W) is OBSERVED. The thermal calculation makes it unlikely to be a permanent bleeder of the main B+ (18.5 W at 430 V > 10 W rating), but its exact function remains ND: bridged inrush limiter, auxiliary-branch bleeder, divider or regulator load are the open alternatives.
The combination MOSFET + TL431 + Bourns makes a regulated auxiliary branch plausible, but its voltage and destination remain ND; a relationship with the 6550 polarisation cannot be ruled out.
The B+ architecture admits three physically distinct readings: (a) separate branches with series R or L, (b) single rail with local bypass, (c) single rail without local bypass. The most conservative reading is PROBABLE single rail with local bypass (b). The numerical coincidence "three capacitors / three branches" does not raise the weight of (a).
The ECC803S is a dual triode. With one ECC803S and one EF86 per channel, the classic combination is EF86 (input) → ECC803S as LTP with both triodes MAIN HYPOTHESIS, supported by the analogy with the Mullard 5-20 (1959, design c. 1956). The required gain is 21–35× (26.5–31.0 dB), compatible with EF86 + LTP + NFB, but that does not prove it. On bias, the two visible trimmers favour "one per channel" over "four individual", but the range remains open. On the operating class: AB probable; AB1 subtype probable with foundation (four convergent observations; see §5.2). Still unknown (ND): global feedback, ultralinear percentage, P@1 %, Zout and DF.
On the Mullard 5-20 lineage: the P52 follows the same valve family as the British reference design (c. 1956, revised 1959), doubled to stereo and with solid-state rectification. This correspondence is a useful argument for inferring the P52 architecture, but does not demonstrate that it reproduces the internal circuit: voltages, polarisation, component values and NFB may differ. The specific NFB figure of the 5-20 does not transfer to the P52, and the literature itself is in conflict (20–26 dB vs ~30 dB depending on the source and revision).
V6.6 reformulation on the driver. Versions earlier than V6.5 described the ECC803S as "the weakest link in the small-signal chain". That claim is not supported: the Ipeak ≈ 0.25 mA calculation is correct, but it does not demonstrate insufficiency, and in probable AB1 there is no DC grid current. The correct conclusion is that the driver's current-delivery capability is an element to verify if the dynamic reserve is to be evaluated, not an established limitation (§3.3). The driver alternatives (6CG7, 6SN7, 12BH7, 5687) are catalogued as TECHNICAL PROPOSAL — PENDING MEASUREMENT (§3.5), not as a justified improvement.
7.3 What cannot be concluded from this report
This list serves to prevent reading more than is there. From photos and catalogues alone, none of the following can be asserted:
- That the P52 actually meets the 40 W at a given THD.
- That the effective filter capacitance is 1,830 µF — it depends on the wiring.
- That the B43645-S7617-M1 code corresponds exactly to the TDK datasheet (ordering code not cross-checked) nor that the family is B43645 and not B43655.
- That the B+ voltage is 450 V or any other value.
- That the 6550 bias mode is fixed by divider, by cathode, from an auxiliary branch, or individual with four trimmers. Probable class is not the same as exact bias mode.
- That the AB1 subtype is confirmed: it is probable with foundation, but not proven. AB2 cannot be ruled out by calculation without a schematic.
- That the class AB is confirmed by the manufacturer in verifiable official documentation.
- That the blue PCB-S trimmers have a bias, inverter DC balance or signal-stage adjustment function, nor exactly how many there are.
- That the 6550s are matched.
- That global NFB exists or its depth. The original Mullard 5-20 figure is in conflict in the literature and, in any case, is not extrapolable to the P52.
- That the ultralinear percentage is the usual 43 % reference.
- That the exact phase-inverter topology is LTP, cathodyne or other. The Mullard 5-20 analogy is PROBABLE / ANALOGY.
- That the Rev.A toroids had a specific inductance of 0.2–0.6 mH: the value is a VISUAL ESTIMATE, not measured. They are not present in the currently photographed unit.
- That there are separate B+ supply branches with series R or L.
- That the 10W10KJ is the main inrush limiter, an auxiliary-branch bleeder, a divider or a regulator load. The only closed point is that it does not appear to be a permanent bleeder of the main B+ under the 430 V hypothesis.
- That PCB-3 performs input selection, mute, protection or any specific function. Only the board and four probably-relay components are observed.
- That the auxiliary magnetic element is an auxiliary transformer, a mains/fuse module or any other specific component. Only the existence of a physical component at that position is observed.
- That a relay-based input selector, a relay-based protection system, or a warm-up timing implemented with a specific component exist.
- That the NE5532 performs DC detection, mute, servo or any specific function.
- That the metal partition is effective for EMI, ground or crosstalk — not measured.
- That the fifth PCB-S hole has a specific function — ND.
- That the gold-plated rear-wall terminals are speaker outputs, inputs or something else — function ND.
- That the P52's ECC803S is insufficient to drive the 6550s. This cannot be asserted without measuring swing, high-frequency distortion and stability into a complex load.
- That the proposed driver alternatives (6SN7, 6CG7, 12BH7, 5687) work better in the P52. They are reasoned technical proposals, not validated. None is plug-and-play.
- That the P52 sounds better or worse than other amplifiers.
PART II — SPECIAL EDITION: WHAT COMPONENTS TO CHANGE OR ADD?
PART II — SPECIAL EDITION: WHAT COMPONENTS TO CHANGE OR ADD?
This part proposes an order of work. Phase 0 — Characterisation (essential before touching anything): measure what the P52 actually is. Then four blocks: A. Safety (high voltage and differential probe). B. Supply and start-up (B+ at idle and under load, ripple, ESR, toroids, auxiliary block, start-up sequence, inrush, relays and cathode current of each 6550). C. Performance (NFB, stability, distortion, P@1 %, Zout and DF, frequency response, noise, THD+N at 4 and 8 Ω). D. Components (C2N, resistors, Bourns, wiring, EMI, brand changes). Finally, S4.
20-second read
What it is: a conditional protocol for a possible special edition of the Acronos P52. It is not a list of improvements or a catalogue of high-end components.
What it contains: in each area, first how the P52 is today and what remains to be known. Where specific components were proposed, they appear separately as AUDIOPHILE PROPOSAL — S3 (listening hypothesis, undemonstrated).
What it is NOT: no change to the P52 is recommended before measuring.
Central idea: the special edition is not defined by a list of expensive components, but by what the characterisation demonstrates is worth changing and by what can then be verified.
Safety warning before any measurement
- At 400 V: E = ½ · 1830·10⁻⁶ · 400² ≈ 146.4 J.
- At 430 V: E = ½ · 1830·10⁻⁶ · 430² ≈ 169.2 J.
- Maximum possible if B+ = 450 V: E ≈ 185.3 J.
Procedure
- Disconnect from mains and ensure it cannot be re-energised.
- Wait, without assuming it has already discharged.
- Measure the remaining voltage with an instrument and approved probes.
- If voltage remains, discharge with a suitable resistor, never with a screwdriver.
- Measure again after a few minutes.
- Only then, with the unit unplugged, attach the measurement clips.
- To measure how the voltage falls: switch on, switch off and read the instrument without touching anything.
- Always use a high-voltage differential probe and approved probes.
S0–S4 scale — definition
| Label | Meaning | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| S0 — Reference | Non-intervention | A valid outcome of the process |
| S1 — Reliability | Changes justified by reliability or safety | Verifiable problem |
| S2 — Performance | Changes with demonstrable electrical improvement | Measurable Δ |
| S3 — Listening | Substitutions evaluated by controlled listening | Reproducible perceptual difference |
| S4 — M&M | Characterisation, matching and documentation | Traceability |
0.1 — Minimum instrumentation
- High-voltage differential probe with its specifications in view.
- Approved probes for the voltage and measurement category.
- Oscilloscope of at least 20 MHz (100 MHz or more for RF/EMI).
- Discharge resistor properly dimensioned.
- IR or contact thermometer.
- LCR/ESR meter (capacitance and series resistance), always with the bank discharged.
1. Coupling capacitors
Photograph 2.jpg shows 16 yellow bodies (11 large and 5 small), 2 gold-coloured and 2 green bodies on the signal board in photograph 2.jpg — OBSERVED. What each C2N does is ND: so many capacitors suggest coupling, bypass, decoupling, compensation, snubber or a mixture.
Audiophile proposal — S3 · LISTENING HYPOTHESIS
- Mundorf MCap EVO Oil / Supreme, ClarityCap CSA / MR, Jupiter HT, V-Cap OIMP / CuTF, Solen Fast Cap, Auricap.
- Note: these are S3 and require a controlled test. They are not presented as a demonstrated improvement.
2. Power-supply capacitors
There are 3 × EPCOS/TDK B43645 (610 µF on at least one part) — OBSERVED. Their wiring is ND. The 1,830 µF is CONDITIONAL CALCULATION (only valid if the three are in parallel). Nominal lifetime of the series: >5,000 h at 105 °C (TDK, REPORTED-EXT).
Audiophile proposal — S3 · LISTENING HYPOTHESIS
- Mundorf MLytic AG / HC — verify they exist in 610 µF, ≥450 V and in the right form factor.
- Nichicon KG / Fine Gold / KW — DISCARD BY VOLTAGE (≤100 V).
- Rubycon MXG / MXH — S3; MXH not verified.
- Jensen / ASC — verify voltage, capacitance and form factor.
3. Resistors
There are green 2 W MOX resistors (10K28) and white 1 W types — OBSERVED. Their function and the power they actually dissipate are ND.
Audiophile proposal — S3
- Plate/cathode signal: Takman Rey, Vishay Dale CMF / RN.
- Feedback and grid stoppers: PRP, Shinkoh, Amtrans AMRG.
- Power: Mills, Ohmite non-inductive.
4. Decoupling and bypass
Their function and values are ND. What is visible: a 100 µF / 450 V capacitor OBSERVED, small electrolytics near the sockets and several auxiliary ones across PCB-P.
Audiophile proposal — S3
- Add or improve the local decoupling of the signal stage with MKP or low-inductance polypropylene capacitors.
- If B+ is a single rail with local bypass (b) or without bypass (c), study series RC networks for the driver and the input (§4.6). Classified as S2 if a measurable difference (Δ) is demonstrated.
5. Internal wiring
Twisted wire bundles are visible — OBSERVED. Their gauge, material and routing are ND.
Audiophile proposal — S3
- Change signal wiring to OCC copper or silver.
- Use appropriately gauged high-voltage and heater wire with Teflon or silicone insulation.
- Keep the current twisting and routing.
6. Supply and protections — PSU V2 and DC Blocker
PSU V2 definition
The PSU V2 is the power supply proposed for a possible revision of the P52, provided the unit has first been characterised.
ORIGINAL EI TRANSFORMER → SILICON RECTIFICATION → MODERATE C1
→ HT CHOKE → MAIN C2
├── POWER B+ ──► 6550
├── R1 + C3 ──► DRIVER B+
└── R2 + C4 ──► INPUT B+
HT filtering choke
If measurements show that the toroids are not audio-frequency chokes, the addition of a 5–10 H choke between C1 and C2 (the first two filter capacitors) would be considered.
Common-mode choke
Only studied if a conducted-EMI measurement demonstrates a mains-induced problem.
X and Y capacitors
The capacitors seen after the IEC connector could not be assigned to class X/Y. If Y capacitors were added, the touch current must be taken into account.
Relays
The Hongfa HF115F is probably the soft-start relay, and the Songle and Finder are auxiliary. Relays with gold contacts are for low-level signals; they are not suitable for switching power.
Soft-start and start-up sequence — open problem
Before modifying anything, the following must be measured: the inrush current, the time taken to charge the HV bank, the delay between mains connection and relay switching, and the behaviour of the Hongfa HF115F and auxiliary relays.
10W10KJ resistor
Marking 10W10KJ; most likely 10 kΩ / 10 W / ±5 %. Its function is ND. The thermal calculation makes it unlikely to be a permanent bleeder of the main B+ (18.5 W at 430 V against a 10 W rating). Open alternatives: bridged inrush limiter, auxiliary-branch bleeder, voltage divider or regulator load.
DC Blocker on the mains input — S1 proposal
A DC Blocker at the IEC inlet is a circuit of two diodes and two anti-parallel electrolytics that prevents the DC component of the mains from reaching the transformer. EI transformers are sensitive to that DC current: a few hundred mV can shift the core's hysteresis cycle, producing mechanical hum, more quiescent current and heating.
Classification: S1 — Reliability. It is not an audiophile proposal (S3), but a reliability measure that lengthens the transformer's life.
Cost: two silicon rectifier diodes (1N5408) and two 10,000–22,000 µF / 10 V electrolytics in anti-parallel.
When to install it: the DC current actually present in the owner's mains must first be measured. If it is negligible (<50 mV), the DC Blocker adds nothing. If it is significant (>200 mV), or if the transformer hums mechanically for a reason other than supply ripple, installation is justified.
ECC803S driver substitution — proposal pending measurement
If characterisation (Phase 0) showed a real driver limitation — for example an anomalous THD increase with frequency, an inability to maintain the required swing into a complex load, or unstable behaviour under NFB — then higher-current-capability valves would be studied. Among the candidates catalogued in §3.5: 6CG7, 6SN7, 12BH7, 5687.
- Verifying the socket pinout and heater consumption.
- Readjusting the driver's bias and operating point.
- Verifying the total loop gain if NFB is present.
- Stability test with square wave at 1 kHz and 10 kHz.
Bias servo — out of scope
NFB switch — discarded as a redesign
Proposals classified by purpose
| Proposal | Classification |
|---|---|
| DC Blocker on the IEC inlet | S1 — conditional on measuring the DC offset |
| Adjust the start-up circuit delay (if its existence and topology are confirmed) | S1 — conditional on resolving the open problem of §6.4 |
| Replace the ECC803S with a 6CG7 / 6SN7 / 12BH7 / 5687 driver | S2 — only if measurement demonstrates a limitation · not plug-and-play · see §3.5 |
| PSU V2: HT filtering choke (5–10 H) + branch separation (R1/C3, R2/C4) if the toroids are not audio-frequency chokes and driver/input modulation is high | S2 if a measurable Δ is demonstrated |
| Common-mode choke on the mains input (Würth WE-CMB or equivalent) | S2 if a measurable Δ is demonstrated |
| Improve or add Y safety capacitors | S1 (safety) — verify touch current |
| Replace relays with Panasonic, Omron or gold-contact types | Low-level signal: S3 · Power/protection: S1. Gold not suitable for power. |
| NFB switch (0/6/12 dB) | DISCARDED — topology redesign |
7. Trimmers (Bourns)
The blue ones (3296 series) are documented with a 100 ppm/°C temperature coefficient; the black ones are ND. Two blue trimmers are visible on PCB-S, one at each end. Their total number and function are ND (see P14).
| Colour / position | Coefficient | Probable function | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blue (PCB-S) | 100 ppm/°C | One per channel: small-signal stage adjustment or inverter DC balance. If there were another two on the underside, they could be individual bias. | TWO OBSERVED one at each end · total number and function ND |
| Blue (PCB-P) | 100 ppm/°C | Auxiliary regulation/control block — exact application ND | PROBABLE |
| Black (PCB-P) | ND | Possible threshold/timing or other — function ND | HYPOTHESIS |
Audiophile proposal — S3
- Blue on PCB-S: Do not fix until its function is known.
- Blues on PCB-P: S1 or S2 depending on function.
- Blacks: S1 or S2 depending on function.
8. S4 — Matched & Measured
S4 does not change components. It is a measurement and documentation layer that can be added to any edition, including S0.
What it includes
- Select and measure the four 6550s one by one.
- Check quiescent current with the valves already mounted.
- Estimate the plate dissipation margin (how much heat each valve can take).
- In ultralinear, the screen current cannot be measured without intervening in the circuit, so the total cathode current is documented.
- Compare the two halves (branches) of the push-pull.
- Compare the regulated auxiliary voltages of the left and right channels.
- Document the relevant electrical measurements.
What "matched" means
- Valve matching: select the valves beforehand, according to measured parameters.
- Installed current matching: check the actual current with the valves already mounted.
- Branch balance: compare the two halves of the push-pull.
- Individual adjustment: only if the circuit allows it (depends on what the blue PCB-S trimmers actually do).
APPENDIX — TECHNICAL QUESTIONNAIRE FOR JUAN CALATAYUD (JC VALVULAR)
Appendix — Technical questionnaire for Juan Calatayud (JC Valvular)
Purpose. These sixteen questions are intended to allow the Acronos P52 designer to answer with his own design and measurement data. His answers would close almost all the ND parameters of the report.
By type of answer requested:
- Design decisions (no measurement): P3, P4, P5, P6, P7, P10, P11, P14, P15, P16.
- Bench measurements (need a production unit): P1, P2, P8, P9, P12.
- Operational and commercial data: P13.
Block 1 — Power and dynamic behaviour
- Actual power at low distortion.
The published 40 W nominal, at what total harmonic distortion (THD) do they correspond? And what is the maximum continuous clean power at 1 % THD into 4 Ω and 8 Ω?
- Output impedance and damping.
What is the measured output impedance (Zout) in the audio band and the damping factor (DF) with 4 Ω and 8 Ω loads? How does the frequency response vary over the actual impedance curve of a loudspeaker with a 4.9 Ω minimum?
- Output transformer taps.
Does the secondary have dedicated 4 Ω and 8 Ω selectable taps, or a single optimised output? What is the optimum load impedance for each tap?
Block 2 — Valves, bias and small-signal architecture
- Bias system and operating class.
How is the bias of the four 6550s adjusted? Are there accessible trimmers, individual or per-pair adjustment, or fixed polarisation by divider or by cathode? What is the target quiescent current value per valve? Are the two blue trimmers visible at the ends of PCB-S associated with signal-stage adjustment or with 6550 bias? Are there other trimmers on the underside? Additional confirmation: is the operating class AB? And the subtype: AB1 (grid never positive with respect to the cathode) or AB2 (grid positive at peaks with grid current)?
- Phase-inverter topology.
What topology does the ECC803S use to invert phase: long-tailed pair (LTP, or cathode-coupled pair), cathodyne/concertina or other? If LTP, does it use both ECC803S triodes?
- Global negative feedback (NFB).
Does the P52 have global negative feedback (NFB)? How much, in dB? How does it contribute to the Zout value that answers question 2?
- Ultralinear percentage (%UL).
At what percentage of the output transformer winding are the screen grids (ultralinear) connected? Is it the usual 43 % reference or different?
Block 3 — Power supply, rails and safety
- Actual B+ voltage and dielectric margin.
What is the actual B+ DC voltage at the 6550 plates and what margin does it keep with respect to the 450 V rating of the EPCOS B43645 capacitors? Does B+ vary between channels?
- HV capacitor bank discharge.
Does the supply have an automatic HV bank discharge circuit on power-off? How long does it take for the residual voltage to fall below 50 V?
- B+ supply architecture and branch separation.
Are the supplies for the 6550s, ECC803S and EF86 separated into independent branches with series resistors or chokes and their own RC networks, or do they share a common B+ rail with local bypass capacitors? If separated, how many branches are there?
- Soft-start and start-up.
How does the circuit manage the high-voltage delay to protect cold cathodes and prevent inrush current on power-up? What function does the Hongfa HF115F relay serve and which specific component performs the timing?
Block 4 — Compatibility, noise and operational data
- Residual noise and loudspeaker compatibility.
What is the audible residual noise level (50/100 Hz hum and hiss) with the input short-circuited? What loudspeaker sensitivity and minimum impedance does the manufacturer recommend to obtain maximum dynamics without clipping?
- Operational data and support.
What is the actual net weight, consumption at idle and at full power, the warranty and service procedure, and is the electrical schematic with test points delivered to the buyer?
- PCB-S trimmers.
How many Bourns trimmers are there on PCB-S and what function does each one have? If two, are they intended for the signal stage or the phase inverter? If there are another two on the underside, are they the individual bias of the four 6550s?
- Function of the 10W10KJ.
Is the 10W10KJ resistor (10 kΩ / 10 W) connected in series with the main B+ (bridged by the Hongfa relay after start-up), or is it on the regulated auxiliary branch? What function does it serve exactly — inrush limiter, auxiliary-branch bleeder, divider or regulator load? What is the programmed delay and which component performs the timing?
- Control architecture and auxiliary elements.
How many functional boards does the P52 have? What function does the vertical PCB-3 with four blue components (probably relays) serve? What is the encapsulated element in the rear-right corner: auxiliary transformer, mains inlet/fuse-holder module, other? If a NE5532 (or similar) IC exists, where does it get its low-voltage supply from? What are the two DIP-8s on PCB-P? What is the function of the gold-plated rear-wall terminals?
The nine critical purchase points
| Point | Associated question | Why it is decisive |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | P1 — Power at 1 % THD | Determines whether the 40 W are usable with clean dynamics |
| 2 | P2 — Zout / DF | Defines the stability of the response over real impedance |
| 3 | P4 — Bias adjustment and operating class | Discriminates between bias topologies and confirms the class |
| 4 | P10 — B+ architecture | Confirms whether the power pulsating current modulates the sensitive stages |
| 5 | P9 — HV bank discharge | Determines physical safety when working inside |
| 6 | P13 — Warranty and schematic | Ensures operational continuity and serviceability |
| 7 | P14 — PCB-S trimmers | Discriminates between alternative bias topologies |
| 8 | P15 — 10W10KJ and timing | Closes the resistor function and the start-up topology |
| 9 | P16 — Control architecture and PCB-3 | Closes the function of PCB-3, the auxiliary element and the origin of Vaux |
APPENDIX — EXTERNAL UNVALIDATED PROPOSALS
Appendix — External unvalidated proposals
Mundorf, ClarityCap, Jupiter, V-Cap, Solen, Auricap, MLytic, Jensen, ASC, Nichicon KW (discarded by voltage for the HV bank), Rubycon MXG/MXH (MXH not verified), Fine Gold, etc. They are retained for traceability of the research process, but they do not constitute a Nauscopio recommendation. Their eventual evaluation is entirely subject to the Phase 0 → A → B → C → D protocol and to a levelled, reproducible S3 test.
REFERENCES AND CREDITS
References and credits
Technical sources
- TDK/EPCOS — Aluminum electrolytic capacitors, snap-in, B43645 / B43655, 610 µF / 450 V. Nominal lifetime >5,000 h at 105 °C (B43645 series per current documentation). Verify full code B43645-S7617-M1 against the ordering-code table. (accessed 2026-10)
- Bourns — 3296 series, 3/8" square trimpot, 25-turn, ±100 ppm/°C. (accessed 2026-09)
- Texas Instruments — TL431 adjustable precision shunt regulator. (accessed 2026-09)
- Texas Instruments — NE5532 dual low-noise operational amplifier. Total supply specified 10–30 V. (accessed 2026-10)
- Hongfa — HF115F miniature high power relay. Family with capacity up to 16 A and 5 kV coil/contact isolation; HF115F-I variant exists for high-inrush loads. (accessed 2026-10)
- JJ Electronic — ECC803S, A.F. twin triode. μ=100, gm=1.6 mA/V, Ri=62.5 kΩ. (accessed 2026-09)
- JJ Electronic — 6550 beam pentode. Wa=35 W, Ua=600 V, Ug2=400 V, If=1.6 A. (accessed 2026-09)
- JJ Electronic — KT88 beam pentode. Wa=42 W, Ua=800 V, Ug2=600 V, If=1.6 A. (accessed 2026-09)
- Mullard Ltd. — Circuits for Audio Amplifiers, 1959 (reprinted 1962; the 5-20 design has been circulating since c. 1956). Contains the reference design of the 5-20 amplifier: EF86 + ECC83 + 2× EL34 push-pull class AB1 + GZ34. THD ≈ 0.1 % at 20 W / 1 kHz. Quoted as a topological analogy in §3.2. (historical document)
- Mullard — EF86, Z729, CV2901, CV4085, small signal pentode. Historical documentation from the mid-1950s. Source of "low hum, low-microphony pentode" and gm = 1.85 mA/V. (historical document 1953)
- Mullard — EL34 Data Sheet. Maximum screen voltage Vg2 ≈ 425 V. (historical document)
- Mullard — ECC83 Data Sheet. Ri = 62.5 kΩ, μ = 100, maximum cathode current ≈ 8–9 mA. (historical document)
- Tube Amp Doctor (TAD) — Technical Data ECC803S (PDF document). Maximum cathode current 8 mA; DC plate voltage 330 V max.; plate dissipation 1.2 W max.; positive grid 0 V max. Source of the datum in §3.3. Tube Amp Doctor · TAD ECC803S (accessed 2026-10)
- TAD (Tube Amp Doctor) — EF86 / 6267 Premium Selected. (accessed 2026-09)
- Genalex / New Sensor — Datasheets KT77 Gold Lion and KT88 Gold Lion. KT77 plate voltage: 800 V per Genalex, 600 V per alternative sources. (accessed 2026-10)
- RCA Receiving Tube Manual RC-30 (1975) and GE Essential Characteristics (1954) — Data for 12AU7, 6SN7, 6CG7, 12BH7 and 5687. Maximum cathode current 6SN7 ≈ 20 mA. Source of the table in §3.5.
- VTL S-200 — Commercial reference for the use of 12BH7 with 6550.
- Sonic Frontiers Power 2 — Commercial reference for the use of 5687 with 8× 6550.
- Conrad-Johnson Premier Eleven — Commercial reference for the use of 6CG7 as a driver.
- Schaffner — FN9244B / FN9280 series IEC inlet filters. (accessed 2026-09)
- Würth Elektronik — WE-CMB common mode chokes. (accessed 2026-09)
Sources on the Acronos P52
- JC Valvular — manufacturing video: Amplificador ACRONOS P52 Una obra de arte. Cómo se fabricó.
- Manufacturer's commercial datasheet — 40 W PP UL with 6550 (no THD condition).
- Blog reader — personal communication: P52 weight ≈ 40 kg. Unverified.
- Interior photographs provided by the unit's owner (2026-10) — verify the B43645-S7617-M1 silkscreen on the EPCOS parts with partially legible markings, identify the Hongfa HF115F relay, confirm the presence of blue Bourns trimmers on PCB-S and document the existence of the vertical PCB-3, the auxiliary magnetic element and the longitudinal metal partition. They also provide the partial readings that support the PROBABLE identifications of the NE5532 and TL431, and the visual non-confirmation of the NE555.
- Field datum (2026-10) — current power of the Acronos M2: 60 W per channel (hybrid). Public distributor datasheets (High End Korner 2024: 50 W; Amigoshifi 2021: 40 W, possibly prototype) outdated with respect to the field unit.
- Technical comparison Acronos P52 vs Cayin Jazz 90 (nauscopio, V3.3, October 2026) — source of the expanded development on the Mullard 5-20 (§3.2), of the conflict in NFB figures of the 5-20 in the literature, and of the reinforcement of the four-observation AB1 argument (§5.2).
Image credits
- Acronos P52 images — manufacturer's video JC Valvular, reproduced for technical analysis purposes.
- Additional images (2026-10) — provided by the unit's owner, reproduced for technical analysis purposes.
- V6.9: incorporation of five SVG technical plates with enlargement.
- V6.10: partial unification of SVG styles and expansion of plate P52-03 on power supply and filtering.
- V6.11: divulgative review with no deliberate loss of technical information and new plate P52-06 on pending measurements.
- V6.11.1 · 12 November 2026: version and date synchronisation, correction of the initial accessible state of the theme toggle and normalisation of SVG attributes. Verified that the external image controller does not intercept the SVG plates. No changes to calculations, plates or conclusions.
- §5.7 — Calculators: an SPL and required-power calculator and a response-variation calculator by Zout are added, both with methodological notes warning that they are pedagogical tools and not P52 measurements.
- Report index: the link to §5.7 (Calculators) is added in the side TOC.
- JSON-LD metadata:
versionupdated to "V6.7"; the historical date recorded was 2026-10-16, although the received JSON-LD declared 2026-10-18. V6.8 unifies the modification date to 2026-11-08. TheeducationalLevelfield is kept as "High school" for the English version. - No changes: general structure, appendices, Part II, measurement protocol, cross-reference system, authorship and all sections §0–§7 (except the addition of §5.7).
