Acronos RS-1, 25-watt single-ended KT150
Reverse-engineering report. It analyses the structural coherence of the declared figures, the class A ceiling and the available loop gain, starting from three house premises: all Acronos use feedback, the valve models are ultralinear and all include an RF/EMI filter on IEC C14.
Images: JC Valvular / Et Sona.
In short: the Acronos RS-1 is a stereo single-ended valve amplifier, 2× KT150, pure class A, with 25 W maximum and 18 W @ 0.01 % THD declared. EC86 NOS → ECC803S NOS → KT150 chain. Ultralinear, with NFB, IEC C14 RF/EMI filter, two threaded fuse holders and custom OPTs.
Clearly established: three house traits confirmed by the manufacturer (NFB in all Acronos, UL in the valve models, RF/EMI filter in all) and custom OPTs different from those of the M1, confirmed in a public video. Probable but unconfirmed: the chassis is inherited from the M1 (five identical parameters); DF ≈ 50 is an OPT design goal, according to the manufacturer's email; the power transformer may hum at 100 Hz due to rectifier peaks. Unknown: NFB depth and type in dB, %UL, real B+, real sensitivity (100 vs 1000 mV), verified mechanical hum, RF/EMI filter brand, fuse values.
Practical decision: with speakers below 90 dB/W/m, the RS-1 is tight. At 3.5 m or in large rooms, 25 W in pure class A leave less than 1 dB of headroom at 100 dB peak. If you expect real measured THD of 0.01 % or DF above 20 with a real load, measure before buying.
GETTING STARTED — WITH NO PRIOR KNOWLEDGE (Basic guide G1–G6)
GETTING STARTED — WITH NO PRIOR KNOWLEDGE
Six ideas are enough to follow the report without having studied electronics. Only A-level physics is needed: logarithms, power and impedance.
Basic guide
An amplifier converts the weak signal from the player (~1 V) into a signal capable of driving a speaker. In a valve amplifier, the preamp increases voltage and the power stage supplies current. Everything is powered by a high DC voltage called B+.
Most domestic amplifiers use push-pull: two power valves work in opposition, and their currents partially cancel. The RS-1 is single-ended (SE): a single power valve per channel. There is no pair, no cancellation.
PUSH-PULL (most): SINGLE-ENDED (RS-1):
Valve A ------+ Single valve ---+
+-- OPT primary +-- OPT primary
Valve B ------+ (balanced ¦ (biased
current) ¦ current)
↓
DC current flows
permanently through
the primary → core
with gap.Three valves per channel: EC86 NOS (preamp), ECC803S NOS (driver + cathode follower) and KT150 (power). Six valves in total.
Advantages of SE. No crossover distortion, linear small-signal transfer, simple structure. Drawbacks. The quiescent current magnetises the core (requires a gap), efficiency is low and Zout without correction is high: it interacts with the speaker and colours the sound.
Pure class A: the valve conducts throughout the entire cycle, without cutting off. The most linear and least efficient: 20–30 % in real use with low THD.
Three house traits of Acronos: all use feedback, the valve models are ultralinear and all incorporate an RF/EMI filter on IEC C14. Starting point of the analysis, not a hypothesis.
A serious report does not treat a measured figure, one published by the manufacturer and a suspicion the same way. Each statement carries an evidence label. The key distinction: DECLARED ≠ CONFIRMED.
| Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| CONFIRMED | Official datasheet, schematic or identifiable independent measurement. |
| MANUFACTURER | Design fact confirmed by the manufacturer. |
| MANUFACTURER-VIDEO | Manufacturer testimony in a public video (the RS-1's custom OPTs). |
| DECLARED | Published without independent verification. |
| OBSERVED | Visible in photographs (8 trimmers, fuse holders). |
| CALCULATED | Formula applied to known data (class A ceiling). |
| PROBABLE | Well-supported inference (Schaffner brand of the filter). |
| ND | Not determinable (NFB depth in dB). |
| MEASURED-EXT | External laboratory measurement (Hi-Fi News). |
The required power depends on the speaker, the distance and the type of music. The dB is logarithmic: +10 dB ×10 power, +3 dB ×2.
For the reference speaker (89 dB/W/m, 3 m):
- 1 W at 1 m: 89 dB.
- Distance loss: 20·log10(3) ≈ 9.54 dB.
- 1 W at 3 m: 79.46 dB.
- 95 dB peak (one speaker): ≈ 35.8 W.
- 100 dB peak (one speaker): ≈ 113 W.
- Decorrelated stereo: 95 dB = 17.9 W/channel; 100 dB = 56.6 W/channel.
After rectifying 50 Hz, the ripple appears at 100 Hz. In PP the two valves receive the ripple in phase and the output transformer rejects it. In SE there is no possible cancellation: the ripple goes straight into the quiescent current, is amplified and appears at the speaker. That is why SE amplifiers use several filtering stages (LC or RC in series).
The B+ ripple with a single capacitor is:
For I = 130 mA and f = 100 Hz, a bank of 220 µF leaves 5.9 V of ripple (1.31 % over B+ 450 V). With 2200 µF it drops to 0.59 V (0.13 %), equivalent to −57.7 dB at the output. To leave it below −80 dB, additional LC or RC stages are needed.
The input RF/EMI filter is not a substitute for B+ filtering. They are two distinct functions: the IEC C14 filter works against conducted high-frequency interference (150 kHz–30 MHz); the HV bank works against low-frequency ripple (100 Hz). An SE needs both.
A "6 Ω" speaker does not always measure 6 Ω: its impedance changes with frequency. Amplifier and speaker form a voltage divider: if Zout is very low, the response is flat; if it is high, it follows the speaker curve and colours the sound. The parameter that summarises it is the damping factor:
The RS-1 paradox. Et Sona declares DF ≈ 50 (Zout ≈ 0.16 Ω over 8 Ω). Precedents with the same valve and topology stay an order of magnitude below. With NFB confirmed, the question is not whether there is a loop, but whether the available depth reaches.
DF is not a single figure. It depends on 12 factors (§4.5) and varies with frequency and load. A DF of 50 measured at 1 kHz with fixed resistors does not describe behaviour at 20 Hz over a real speaker.
- The RS-1 is single-ended (one KT150 per channel), ultralinear, with NFB, with an IEC C14 RF/EMI filter and with two threaded fuse holders. All by house policy. The output transformers are custom-made, confirmed by the manufacturer in a video.
- It declares two THD points (18 W @ 0.01 % and 25 W @ 0.5 %) and a DF ≈ 50 published by Et Sona. Precedents with SE KT150 are far below.
- With 89 dB speakers at 3 m, the 25 W are at the limit. Manufacturer recommends 90 dB minimum.
- The class A ceiling constrains B+: 25 W with 130 mA bias require B+ = 385 V theoretical, ~478 V practical. The available NFB is not enough either for DF 50 or, much less, for THD 0.01 %. The power transformer may hum at 100 Hz.
PART I — ACRONOS RS-1 REPORT
From the declared figure to the verifiable hypothesis.
0. Executive summary
20-second read
What it is. Stereo single-ended, 2× KT150, pure class A, 25 W max., 18 W @ 0.01 % THD. EC86 NOS → ECC803S NOS → KT150 chain. Ultralinear, with NFB, IEC C14 RF/EMI filter, two threaded fuse holders and custom OPTs (MANUFACTURER-VIDEO).
Central finding. Under the §4.3 model, the 0.01 % THD at 18 W demands 49–54 dB of reduction; the declared DF of ~50 corresponds to 31.7 dB as an impedance ratio. These are conditional figures, not physical equivalences.
Loop calculation. Available: 21–29 dB with 100 mV sensitivity. Below the threshold: under the model, neither H1 (0.1–0.45 %) nor H2 with cathode feedback (0.025–0.089 %) reaches 0.01 %.
Class A ceiling. 25 W with 130 mA bias require B+ = 384.6 V theoretical; ~478 V practical.
General description
The Acronos RS-1 is a single-ended pure class A valve amplifier, with one KT150 per channel, 25 W maximum and 18 W @ 0.01 % THD declared. Chain: EC86 NOS → ECC803S NOS → KT150. Evolution of the Acronos M1 (KT120, 20 W). Manufacturer: JC Valvular (Juan Calatayud), Málaga.
Three house premises, confirmed by the manufacturer: all Acronos use feedback, the valve models are ultralinear and all incorporate an RF/EMI filter on IEC C14. Furthermore, in a public video, the manufacturer confirms that the RS-1 output transformers are custom-made, commissioned with specifications different from those of the M1 MANUFACTURER-VIDEO.
Provisional conclusion
The RS-1 sits between commercial KT150 SE amplifiers (DF ≈ 7–9) and declared figures of another category. We know there is NFB, that the OPTs are custom-made and that the chassis is probably inherited from the M1. But the loop gain calculation (§4.3) leaves a narrow or negative margin. The outcome depends on a data point the manufacturer can provide in one sentence: how much NFB, in dB, and of what type, does the RS-1 have? And on an acoustic verification: does the power transformer hum?
1. Scope, method and limitations
This chapter does not assess how the RS-1 sounds. It explains what we know about it, where each data point comes from and how reliable it is. It is an exercise in reverse engineering without a schematic from the manufacturer. That is why every statement carries a label.
- Direct contact with JC Valvular. It confirms three house policies that apply to all Acronos: 1) All use negative feedback, NFB. 2) All valve models are ultralinear, UL. 3) All carry an RF/EMI mains filter on the IEC C14 connector. Brand unspecified, probably Schaffner. MANUFACTURER
- Public video of Juan Calatayud. He declares that the RS-1 transformers are different from those of the M1 and that he had to commission them custom-made with other specifications. This data point is key: it resolves the debate about whether the same transformer is reused. MANUFACTURER-VIDEO
- RS-1 commercial spec sheet. 25 W maximum, 18 W @ 0.01 % THD, 130 mA bias, 195 W consumption, 20 Hz – 40 kHz response, 100 kΩ input impedance, 100 mV sensitivity, 14 kg weight, 45×26×11 cm dimensions. Valves: 1× KT150 + 1× ECC803S + 1× EC86 per channel. The 100 mV sensitivity is ND: we do not know whether it is for a pure power stage or for an integrated with the potentiometer at maximum.
- Et Sona review. It confirms lineage: "On the website you will find the M1 with KT120, but this time we have the RS-1 which uses KT150s". It publishes DF ≈ 50 and describes a 1.5 mm carbon steel chassis, solid wood panels and 22 mm feet.
- Official M1 spec sheet. From jcvalvular.com, January 2023. 20 W max., 18 W @ 0.01 % at 1 kHz, 100 kΩ, 100 mV, 14 kg, 45×26×11 cm, KT120 in class A ultralinear. Same 5 parameters as the RS-1. DECLARED
- Measured precedents. Icon Audio ST30SE (Hi-Fi News 2019.11): 26 kg net / 28 kg packed, 28 W in UL, Zout 0.85–1.17 Ω. Dared Saturn Signature: 25 W SE KT150, 18 kg. Fiio EA13: push-pull class A 4× EL34, 17.7 kg, with documented mechanical hum at 100 Hz.
- Datasheets. KT150 Tung-Sol: 70 W maximum plate dissipation, heater 1.75–2.0 A. Example point in pentode class A1: 400 V, 150–180 mA, 20 W with 14 % THD. EC86 Philips: VHF triode, µ = 68, gm = 14 mA/V, ra ≈ 4.86 kΩ.
- Photographs. Interior (two boards, 8 trimmers, point-to-point) and rear panel (IEC, fuses, RCA, terminals). OBSERVED
- Reference system. Crossover A v2.4 MR-A-01 (6 Ω nom / Zmin 4.9 Ω / 89 dB/W/m), listening at 3 m.
Catalogue context — JC Valvular range
| Model | Topology | Power | Category |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acronos M1 | SE Class A with KT120, ultralinear | 20 W | Genealogical predecessor of the RS-1 |
| Acronos RS-1 | SE Class A with KT150, ultralinear | 25 W max. / 18 W @ 0.01 % | Subject of this report |
| Acronos P52 | Push-Pull Ultralinear (4× 6550) | 40 W nominal | Dedicated report |
| Acronos M2 | Hybrid | 60 W | High native DF without relying on the OPT |
A single-ended (SE) uses a single valve per channel. It is pure class A, always conducting. A push-pull (PP) uses two valves that alternate. It does not need a gap and weighs less per watt.
M1 and RS-1 share five exact parameters. That points to an inherited mechanical platform. The manufacturer's video clarifies the key point: the RS-1 OPTs are custom-made, different from those of the M1. The fact that total weight coincides suggests that the redesign has not been massive, but it does not prove it. The full physical analysis is in §2.2.
The five shared parameters
| Parameter | M1 (KT120) | RS-1 (KT150) |
|---|---|---|
| Total weight | 14 kg | 14 kg |
| Dimensions | 45 × 26 × 11 cm | 45 × 26 × 11 cm |
| THD at 1 kHz | 18 W @ 0.01 % | 18 W @ 0.01 % |
| Input impedance | 100 kΩ | 100 kΩ |
| Sensitivity | 100 mV | 100 mV |
Five parameters nailed. To the millimetre and to the decimal. The maximum power does change: 20 W in the M1, 25 W in the RS-1. The power valve also changes: KT120 vs. KT150. But the distortion point —the most extraordinary figure in the report— does not move.
The three lineage scenarios
| Scenario | Chassis | OPT | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| A — Full same platform | Inherited from M1 | Inherited from M1 | DISCARDED by the video: the OPTs are custom-made. |
| B — Inherited chassis, custom OPTs | Inherited from M1 | Redesigned, different from M1 | MANUFACTURER-VIDEO for the fact of the redesign. |
| C — Modified chassis | Slightly adapted for KT150 | New | PROBABLE but marginal. |
What does "custom-made" mean in an SE?
It does not automatically mean "bigger". It means that electrical parameters are changed to adapt the KT150:
- B+: plate supply voltage.
- Ibias: 130 mA that the primary must support without saturating.
- Raa: impedance seen by the valve, typically 3 kΩ in KT150.
- Gap: core air gap. It sets how much DC current it withstands.
- Lp: primary inductance to reach 20 Hz.
If the total weight remains at 14 kg and the external volume does not change, what is probable is that the redesign is moderate in mass. There is no obvious room for much more copper or iron. What changes more easily is N (number of turns) and the gap.
- We work without a schematic, with spec sheets, photos, precedents and video testimony from the manufacturer. Every statement carries an evidence label.
- M1 and RS-1 share 5 identical parameters (weight, dimensions, THD at 1 kHz, 100 kΩ, 100 mV), which indicates the same mechanical platform. The inherited chassis is PROBABLE.
- Calatayud's video confirms custom OPTs, different from the M1. The magnitude of the redesign is ND: the identical weight suggests a moderate change, but does not prove it.
2. Architecture and power supply
Architecture is the set of functional blocks and how they are connected. In the RS-1 there are three: power supply, signal chain and output. Topology SE ultralinear with NFB and input RF/EMI filter, by house policy. The OPTs are custom-made. The diagram is a hypothetical reconstruction, not a manufacturer's schematic. This chapter examines the diagram, the chassis, the transformers, the power supply and the risk of mechanical hum from the transformer.
MAINS 230 V
¦
+-- [IEC C14 · RF/EMI filter --- MANUFACTURER] --- brand/model ND · Schaffner?
¦ ¦
¦ +-- [2× threaded fuse holders rear panel --- OBSERVED]
¦ (live+neutral or mains+B+? ND · values ND)
¦
+-- Power transformer --- OBSERVED · hum? ND
¦
↓
SOLID-STATE RECTIFICATION (probable) → LC/RC filtering (topology ND)
¦
↓
B+ (voltage ND) ------→ KT150 channel L (UL)
+--→ KT150 channel R (UL)
SIGNAL CHAIN PER CHANNEL (DECLARED by Et Sona)
[RCA in ×3 + Muting] → [EC86 NOS · preamp]
→ [ECC803S NOS · driver + cathode follower]
→ [KT150 · UL power]
→ [Custom SE output transformer · gap] → [4 Ω / 8 Ω speaker]
+-- NFB loop from secondary to driver (MANUFACTURER)
Ultralinear mode --------------- MANUFACTURER
NFB (exists) -------------------- MANUFACTURER
NFB depth in dB ----------------- ND (central question)
%UL ----------------------------- ND
Bias 130 mA --------------------- DECLARED
Sensitivity 100 mV -------------- DECLARED · nature ND
IEC C14 RF/EMI filter ----------- MANUFACTURER
Threaded fuse holders ----------- OBSERVED · function and values ND
Custom OPTs, different from M1 --- MANUFACTURER-VIDEO
B+ = 385 V for 25 W class A ----- CALCULATED (§3.2)
8 trimmers --- OBSERVED · individual function ND
Power transformer hum ----------- ND · PROBABLE risk
Total weight does not say whether an amplifier sounds better. But it says a lot about the size of the transformers. The comparison between the three commercial KT150 SEs is what matters: Icon 26 kg, Dared 18 kg, RS-1 14 kg. Same valve, same physics, 12 kg difference. This block also examines the physical reason why an SE weighs more per watt than a PP: the OPT air gap.
Why an SE weighs more per watt than a PP
In SE the quiescent current always flows through the primary of the output transformer. That DC magnetises the core and would saturate it. To avoid it, a cut is made: the air gap or gap.
The gap lowers the effective permeability from 10,000 to about 200. The formula governing inductance is:
If μeff drops 50 times, to maintain the same Lp, N must be multiplied by 7. That is 7 times more copper and a much larger window. In practice, an SE OPT is 3 to 5 times bulkier than a PP one.
The minimum inductance to avoid losing bass is:
With Raa = 3 kΩ and fc = 20 Hz → Lp ≈ 24 H minimum. For flat response at 20 Hz, 60–70 H are needed.
Comparative table with kg/W, volume and density
| Model | Topology | Power | Weight | Volume | Density | kg/W | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Icon ST30SE | SE KT150, UL | 28 W | 26 kg net | ND | ND | 0.93 | MEASURED-EXT |
| Acronos M1 | SE KT120, UL | 20 W | 14 kg | 12.87 L | 1.09 g/cm³ | 0.70 | DECLARED |
| Dared Saturn | SE KT150, triode | 25 W | 18 kg | ND | ND | 0.72 | MEASURED-EXT |
| Acronos RS-1 | SE KT150, UL | 25 W | 14 kg | 12.87 L | 1.09 g/cm³ | 0.56 | DECLARED |
| Cayin Jazz 90 | PP AB1 KT88 | 50 W | 27.5 kg | 34.21 L | 0.80 g/cm³ | 0.55 | CONFIRMED |
| Fiio EA13 | PP A EL34 | 18 W | 17.7 kg | 21.10 L | 0.84 g/cm³ | 0.98 | MEASURED-EXT |
What weight says and what it does NOT say
The coincidence of weight and dimensions between M1 and RS-1 is compatible with a moderate redesign in mass: same mechanical platform, different electrical specifications (gap, N, Raa). But it does not prove it: the same weight could hide a different OPT with a very different internal mass distribution. Without measurements, comparable photographs or core and winding data, the exact magnitude of the redesign is ND.
What is ruled out is a massive redesign. If the new OPT had much more iron or copper, the total weight would have risen from 14 to 16–18 kg. It has not. The 12 kg difference with the Icon ST30SE admits three explanations, all compatible with the data: (a) smaller RS-1 OPTs; (b) lighter chassis (Et Sona documents 1.5 mm steel + solid wood + 22 mm feet); (c) some component not included in the declared weight. It is resolved by measuring Lp and the 20 Hz response at full power.
Weight does not say which one sounds better. A heavier amplifier is not better for being heavier. Nor does it say whether it is undersized: the right question is not "why does the RS-1 weigh so little?" but "is the light one undersized or the heavy one oversized?". The Jazz 90 case (0.55 kg/W, almost identical to the RS-1) illustrates that the ratio is not comparable between devices with different integration: the Jazz carries DAC, Bluetooth, phono and protections; the RS-1 is a minimalist amplifier with three RCA inputs.
- An SE weighs 3–5× more per watt than a PP because of the OPT air gap. The RS-1 declares 14 kg, 12 kg less than the Icon ST30SE with the same valve.
- The coincidence of weight with the M1 suggests a moderate redesign, but does not prove it. The exact magnitude is ND. The volumetric density (1.09 g/cm³) is the highest in the comparison group.
- Power/mass ratio 13.9 W/kg: descriptive, not thermal density. The 12 kg difference with the Icon is resolved by measuring Lp and 20 Hz response at full power.
Everything behind the IEC C14 and everything that can vibrate there. The RF/EMI filter works against conducted high-frequency interference (150 kHz–30 MHz). The HV bank of the B+ works against low-frequency ripple (100 Hz). They are two distinct functions and an SE needs both. Added: the power transformer, with pure class A as the regime of maximum demand, can vibrate mechanically at 100 Hz from two motors —Lorentz and magnetostriction—. It is the third finding of the report.
B+ ripple translated to dB at the output
In an SE, the B+ ripple is not cancelled. With ΔVripple ≈ I / (f · C), for I = 130 mA and f = 100 Hz:
| HV bank capacitance | ΔVripple | Ratio to B+ 450 V | Theoretical output attenuation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 220 µF | 5.9 V | 1.31 % | −37.6 dB |
| 470 µF | 2.8 V | 0.62 % | −44.2 dB |
| 1000 µF | 1.3 V | 0.29 % | −50.8 dB |
| 2200 µF | 0.59 V | 0.13 % | −57.7 dB |
For the ripple to remain below −80 dB at the output with a typical PSRR of 30–40 dB in an SE, additional LC or RC stages adding 30–40 dB more filtering are needed. A single capacitor is not enough.
RF/EMI filter, fuse holders and safety
The RS-1 has two threaded fuse holders on the rear panel, old style: screw or bayonet caps, separate from the IEC C14.
Why two fuses?
| Configuration | Implication | Probability |
|---|---|---|
| Live and neutral on mains | Double pole. Extra safety if the plug is reversed. | More probable |
| Mains + B+ HT | One slow (T1.6A–T2A), one fast (F315–500mA). | Probable if the values are different |
| One per channel | SE with two independent transformers. | Unlikely |
Double fuse + RF/EMI filter on IEC C14 is typical of a product intended for sale: safety regulation compliance. An indication of a commercial product, not a home workshop.
Compatibility with the reference speaker
| Scenario | Zout | Δ level Zmin ↔ Znom | DF @ 6 Ω |
|---|---|---|---|
| If DF 50 were real | 0.16 Ω | ≈ 0.28 dB | 37.5 |
| Icon ST30SE (UL) | 1.0 Ω | ≈ 1.6 dB | 6.0 |
| Icon ST30SE (triode) | 0.5 Ω | ≈ 0.85 dB | 12.0 |
| No NFB (typical SET) | 2.5–4 Ω | ≈ 3.5–5 dB | 1.5–2.4 |
With 0.28 dB the response is essentially flat over this speaker. With 1.6 dB (Icon UL) there is already audible coloration in the woofer crossover region. With 3.5–5 dB (SET without correction), the response literally follows the speaker's impedance curve. You can explore the effect with the Zout calculator.
Mechanical hum from the power transformer
Pure class A subjects the power transformer to a constant and maximum load. The current peaks from the rectifier can make the windings vibrate at 100 Hz due to two motors: Lorentz force on the copper and magnetostriction of the core. The chassis can amplify it like a sound box. It is not DC on the mains: it is load stress. The Fiio EA13 documents the mechanism. The RS-1 uses the same 1.5 mm steel chassis with solid wood panels as its predecessor M1. That chassis was designed for a KT120 at 20 W. With the KT150 at 25 W, the transformer works harder on the same anti-vibration mounting.
Cause-effect table
| Cause | Frequency | DC Blocker? | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|---|
| DC on the mains | 50 Hz (hum) | Yes | DC blocker |
| Rectifier peaks | 100 Hz (buzz) | No | More HV capacitance, NTC |
| Core magnetostriction | 100 Hz | No | Core with glued joints |
| Lorentz force | 100 Hz | No | Fixed coils, silentblocks |
| Chassis-transformer coupling | 100 Hz amplified | No | Wood panels, silentblocks |
Precedent: Fiio EA13
Push-pull class A, 17.7 kg, 21.1 L. Users report audible buzz at 3–4 m. Fiio tried to prevent it with OPTs encapsulated in resin and sand, a unibody aluminium chassis and anti-vibration feet. It still hums: what vibrates is the power transformer. The RS-1 has a power/mass ratio of the same order (13.9 W/kg vs 12.4–13.0 W/kg for the EA13) and less mass and volume. The verification is binary and without instrumentation: listen at 10 cm after 1 h hot with the Spectroid app.
- Supply: RF/EMI filter (150 kHz–30 MHz) + HV bank of the B+ (100 Hz) are two distinct functions. Ripple: a single capacitor gives −37 to −51 dB; for −80 dB, LC/RC stages are needed. ND.
- Two threaded fuse holders + IEC C14 filter indicate a commercial product, not a home workshop. Values and model: ND.
- Hum: two motors at 100 Hz (Lorentz + magnetostriction). EA13 precedent with less margin. Acoustic and binary verification. Risk PROBABLE.
3. Chain and power stage
Three valves per channel: EC86 (preamp), ECC803S (driver + cathode follower), KT150 (UL power). This chapter covers the chain that feeds the KT150 and everything around the KT150: operating point, pure class A, bias, dissipation, class A ceiling and ultralinear operation. Two dense sub-sections.
Total: six valves (two KT150, two ECC803S, two EC86).
| Stage | Valve | Type | Function |
|---|---|---|---|
| Preamp | EC86 NOS | UHF triode | Initial amplification. NOS for linearity and low noise. µ = 68. |
| Driver | ECC803S NOS | Double triode | One triode drives; the other, cathode follower. |
| Power | KT150 | Beam tetrode | Pure class A ultralinear. |
EC86 data
Single triode for UHF. Data confirmed from the Philips/NXP datasheet at 175 V and 12 mA: µ = 68, gm = 14 mA/V, ra ≈ 4.86 kΩ CONFIRMED. Max plate: 220 V. Equivalent: 6CM4.
ECC803S data
Long-plate premium version of the ECC83 / 12AX7 family. One triode amplifies voltage, the other acts as a cathode follower (gain ~1, very low Zout) to isolate from the KT150 input capacitance (Miller effect).
Gain per stage
With typical ideal loads, A = µ · RL / (RL + ra):
| Stage | µ | ra | RL | Av (dB) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC86 | 68 | 4.86 kΩ | 47 kΩ | 35.8 |
| ECC803S | 100 | 62 kΩ | 100 kΩ | 35.8 |
| KT150 (UL) | — | 3.5 kΩ | 1.5 kΩ | 25.5 |
Total at the plate: 61.6 × 61.7 × 18.9 ≈ 71,899 ≈ 97.1 dB.
The KT150 is octal, successor to the KT120 and KT88, with 70 W maximum plate dissipation according to Tung-Sol CONFIRMED. Heater: 1.75–2.0 A.
| Feature | KT150 | KT120 |
|---|---|---|
| Max plate dissipation | 70 W | 60 W |
| Max plate voltage | 850 V pent. / 650 V triode | 700 V |
| Heater | 1.75–2.0 A | ~1.7–1.95 A |
The 130 mA bias is consistent with pure class A. At B+ = 400–450 V: 52–58.5 W per valve, within the 70 W maximum with a margin of 16–26 %. The declared consumption of 195 W breaks down into heaters (~32 W), plates (~104 W), drivers (~10 W) and losses (20–30 W). That gives 166–176 W: the declared figure is 10–15 % higher, plausible as a catalogue figure rounded upwards.
Pure class A: implications
- Practical efficiency: 20–30 % with low THD and real music.
- Theoretical efficiency limit: ~48 % (25 / (400 × 0.13)).
- High linearity: no crossover distortion.
- Distortion dominated by even harmonics.
- Soft clipping: progressively compresses.
Dissipation per valve according to B+
| B+ | Estimated Pplate | % of maximum (70 W) |
|---|---|---|
| 425 V | 55.25 W | 78.9 % |
| 450 V | 58.50 W | 83.6 % |
| 478 V | 62.14 W | 88.8 % |
| 500 V | 65.00 W | 92.9 % |
Above 83 % of maximum throughout the 450–500 V range. Indicative service life of 2000–4000 h before emission drops noticeably (ND specific to the RS-1). Expected temperature: OPT 45–55 °C, transformer 55–70 °C. It implies not enclosing it, leaving 5–10 cm free and not stacking it. Without published thermography, it is PROBABLE.
Bias: the 8 trimmers and thermal drift
The 130 mA bias sustains the entire class A ceiling. If it drifts, Pmax changes and with it the 25 W figure. In the photos, 8 blue and black Bourns trimmers can be seen:
| Trimmer | Board | Hypothesis |
|---|---|---|
| 1–2 (blue Bourns) | Signal | Bias per KT150 (one per channel) |
| 3–4 (blue Bourns) | Signal | EC86 operating point or ECC803S driver balance |
| 5–8 (2 blue + 2 black) | Power | NFB loop compensation (pole, zero), per channel |
The whole map is ND until the board is traced with a multimeter. Indirect measurement without a schematic: measure the drop across the cathode resistor (typically 10 Ω), I = V / R. For 130 mA and Rk = 10 Ω: 1.30 V expected.
Class A ceiling
In a class A SE, the maximum theoretical power is limited by B+ and quiescent current:
Table A — Ideal theoretical limit (without primary Rdc or Vknee)
| B+ | Pmax | Margin over 25 W | Achievable in practice? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 384.6 V | 25.00 W | 0 W — exact limit | No: losses lower it |
| 425 V | 27.62 W | +2.62 W (10.5 %) | No: Vknee and Rdc consume the margin |
| 450 V | 29.25 W | +4.25 W (17 %) | Tight: with low losses |
| 500 V | 32.50 W | +7.50 W (30 %) | Yes |
Table B — Practical minimum with real losses
| B+ | Interpretation | Compatible with 25 W class A? |
|---|---|---|
| 385 V | Theoretical limit without losses | No |
| 430 V | With Vknee, without ohmic losses | No |
| 478 V | Practical minimum | Tight |
| 500 V | Comfortable zone | Yes |
450–500 V is not optimistic, it is the minimum practical range. If the real B+ were below ~430 V, the 25 W figure would include excursion outside class A.
Operating mode: ultralinear
Manufacturer confirms UL in all valve Acronos. In UL, the screen grid is connected to an intermediate tap of the OPT primary. The %UL decides how much it resembles a triode or a pentode. Typical values 20–50 %.
| Mode | Expected power | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Pure pentode SE | ~20 W @ THD = 14 % | DISCARDED |
| Pure triode SE | 12–18 W | DISCARDED |
| Ultralinear SE + NFB | 20–30 W with low THD | CONFIRMED |
- Chain: EC86 (µ = 68) → ECC803S (dual function) → KT150 (UL power). The cathode follower does not explain DF ≈ 50. Gross gain at the plate ~97 dB.
- KT150: 70 W max. 130 mA bias, 8 trimmers (map ND), dissipation 79–93 % depending on B+. No drift data at 500 h.
- Class A ceiling: B+ = 384.6 V theoretical (without losses), ~478 V practical. UL confirmed, %UL ND. Service life 2000–4000 h. Expected temperature OPT 45–55 °C, transformer 55–70 °C.
4. The central question: how much NFB?
Manufacturer confirms NFB in all Acronos. What is not known is how much. NFB lowers Zout (raises DF), lowers THD and widens bandwidth. It is the candidate mechanism to explain the two extraordinary figures. The question: is the available NFB enough for DF ≈ 50 and THD 0.01 % at 18 W?
| Source | Power | THD | Configuration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tung-Sol KT150 | 20 W | = 14 % | Pure pentode, class A1, no NFB |
| Acronos RS-1 (declared) | 18 W | 0.01 % | Ultralinear + NFB |
Three orders of magnitude. It is not a contradiction: it is what UL + NFB contributes.
How much NFB the THD demands
49–54 dB of loop gain for THD alone. The declared DF of ~50 corresponds, in the §4.3 model, to 31.7 dB. These are two different quantities —one is loop gain, the other an impedance ratio— and should not be compared as if they were the same measurement.
Standard procedure: two known, different resistive loads.
There is a preferable variant for valve amplifiers: the two-load method, which avoids measuring in open circuit. Since the output transformer is inductive, measuring without load can generate overvoltages that damage the transformer or the valves. That is why this report uses the two-load method, which is also the one JC Valvular applies in its design routine.
Two-load method
- Load R1 = 8 Ω, inject 1 kHz, measure V1.
- Load R2 = 4 Ω, measure V2.
- Calculate:
- DF = 8 / Zout.
- Repeat at several frequencies (20 Hz – 20 kHz). The curve matters.
Base model. KT150 in UL with effective ra ~3.5 kΩ, OPT with n = 25, 100 mV sensitivity.
- Open Zout. 3500/625 + 0.7 ≈ 6.3 Ω → DFol ≈ 1.27.
- Necessary reduction. From 1.27 to 50: factor 39.4.
- Loop gain: β·A ≈ 38.4 → 31.7 dB.
Unified model sensitivity table
| raUL | Raa | Loop needed for DF 50 | Verdict with 21–29 dB available |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3.5 kΩ | 5 kΩ (n = 25) | 31.7 dB | Does not reach |
| 1.5–2 kΩ | 5 kΩ (n = 25) | 26–28 dB | H1 revives |
| 3.5 kΩ | 3 kΩ (n ≈ 19.4) | ~36 dB | Does not reach |
| 3.5 kΩ | 3 kΩ, with CF ×5 | ~12–15 dB + CF | Yes |
Is 31.7 dB achievable?
| Scenario | Gross | After OPT | Closed | Loop | Exact DF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Optimistic | 100 dB | 72.04 dB | 43.01 dB | 29.03 dB | 37.2 |
| Typical | 95 dB | 67.04 dB | 43.01 dB | 24.03 dB | 21.5 |
| Realistic | 92 dB | 64.04 dB | 43.01 dB | 21.03 dB | 15.6 |
In the best case, 29 dB, below the 31.7 dB needed. For THD: with 21–29 dB of loop and 3–5 % open-loop in UL, the final THD would be 0.1–0.45 %. 20–33 dB missing.
Central finding — traffic light table
- 31.7 dB is the Zout reduction factor needed to go from 6.3 Ω (open loop) to 0.16 Ω (DF ≈ 50). It is an impedance ratio.
- 49–54 dB is the voltage loop gain needed to reduce THD in the declared proportion. It is a voltage ratio.
Analogy. If you measure a car's speed downhill on the best stretch of a motorway, you get 200 km/h. If you measure the average speed over a complete journey with curves, climbs and descents, you get 80 km/h. Both data points are true, but they describe different things. The same can happen with DF: the catalogue figure and the overall behaviour of the amplifier with real speakers do not necessarily coincide. That is exactly the point that forces measurement, not extrapolation.
Methodological note. The declared figures are DECLARED; the available loop is CALCULATED from typical gains at the plate and 100 mV sensitivity. The three results change completely if the real sensitivity is 1000 mV (§4.4).
If the real sensitivity were 1000 mV instead of 100 mV, the closed-loop gain would drop to 23.01 dB and the loop would rise to 41–49 dB. It is the only scenario where H1 revives without cathode feedback.
| Sensitivity | Acl | Loop | THD without CF | THD with CF ×5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 mV | 43.01 dB | 21–29 dB | 0.1–0.45 % | 0.02–0.09 % |
| 1000 mV | 23.01 dB | 41–49 dB | 0.011–0.045 % | 0.002–0.009 % |
THD vs. power chart — the four key curves
Juan Calatayud has replied by email to the report's questions.
Key points
- DF is complex in valves ("infinitely easier" in solid state).
- It is calculated in the OPT design, not measured at the end.
- The DF ≈ 50 figure is an "average DF", measured at 1 kHz with fixed resistive loads.
- It is not constant: it varies with frequency and with the reflected speaker impedance.
- Does not mention how much NFB in dB, nor %UL, nor cathode feedback.
The 12 DF factors according to the manufacturer
| # | Factor |
|---|---|
| 1 | Internal impedance of the output valves |
| 2 | Stage configuration (pentode, tetrode, triode, UL) |
| 3 | OPT transformation ratio |
| 4 | Primary winding resistance |
| 5 | Secondary winding resistance |
| 6 | Global negative feedback |
| 7 | Local feedback |
| 8 | OPT leakage inductance |
| 9 | Primary magnetising inductance |
| 10 | OPT parasitic capacitances |
| 11 | Wiring and connections |
| 12 | Operating frequency and load |
Methodological warning — the Fezz case
click to expand
The Fezz Titania line: PA MK2 (declares DF > 40) and PA Evolution (measured by HiFiNews with DF = 1). They are different models, but they illustrate that declared figures can differ radically from measured ones.
- Central finding: the model estimates that THD 0.01 % at 18 W requires 49–54 dB; the declared DF of ~50 corresponds to 31.7 dB. The three verdicts in the traffic light table of §4.3.
- Loop needed: 31.7 dB for DF 50; available 21–29 dB with 100 mV. With 1000 mV: loop 41–49 dB, THD 0.011–0.045 % without CF. It is the only scenario where H1 revives.
- Manufacturer's response (§4.5): DF is designed in the OPT, 12 factors, average at 1 kHz with resistive loads. It confirms the methodological suspicion, reinforces H2/H4, leaves NFB open.
5. Precedents and hypotheses
Precedents are the empirical floor: what others have achieved with the same valve in an SE. Hypotheses are the theoretical ceiling: which architectures would explain the declared figures. Together they define the space of the possible. The Icon ST30SE is the most relevant precedent (same valve, same SE topology with gap). The Fiio EA13 provides the hum precedent. The Dared Saturn is inconsistent and does not serve as a ceiling.
Comparative table of precedents
| Parameter | Icon ST30SE | Dared Saturn | Fiio EA13 | Acronos RS-1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| KT150/channel | 1 | 1 | No (4× EL34) | 1 |
| Topology | SE, UL/triode switchable, switchable NFB | SE triode | PP Class A | SE class A UL |
| Weight | 26 kg net | 18 kg | 17.7 kg | 14 kg |
| Consumption | 177 W / 220 W | ND | 220 W / 230 W | 195 W |
| NFB | "low feedback" switchable ND | −39 dB (inconsistent) | ND | Exists; depth ND |
| DF | UL: 7–9 · TR: 15–17 HiFiNews · ≈ 6 Hi-Fi World | 6 | ND | ≈ 50 (Et Sona) |
| Buzz reported | ND | ND | Yes | ND |
Icon ST30SE — the most relevant precedent
Measured by Hi-Fi News in 2019: Zout 0.85–1.17 Ω in UL and 0.47–0.54 Ω in triode. Power 28 W in UL / 18 W in triode. THD 0.2–0.5 % at 1–5 W, 1 % at 17 W, 2 % at 30 W. Weighs 26 kg net. The UL connection has higher Zout than triode. The H/L/0 feedback switch allows removing or reducing NFB. It is a real precedent that DF depends on the loop.
Fiio EA13 — the hum precedent
Push-pull class A, 4× EL34, 18 W < 1 %, 17.7 kg, 21.1 L. It documents mechanical buzz from the power transformer despite OPTs encapsulated in resin and sand, a unibody chassis and anti-vibration feet. Direct precedent for §2.3.
Dared Saturn — inconsistent
SE triode with KT150. Declares: 25 W/channel, −39 dB global NFB, DF 6, THD 0.05 % at 4 W. Weight: 18 kg. The numbers do not add up: with −39 dB of NFB (factor ≈ 89.1), Zout should be reduced by that factor. With open Zout of 5–6 Ω, the final would be ~0.06 Ω (DF ≈ 130). Declaring DF 6 with −39 dB implies that one of the data points does not mean what it appears to. It does not serve as an empirical ceiling.
Architecture hypotheses
Three live hypotheses to explain the RS-1's declared figures:
- H1 — Deep global NFB with higher gain than estimated. With 100 mV sensitivity: THD 0.1–0.45 %. Does not reach. With 1000 mV, H1 revives (§4.4).
- H2 — Cathode feedback + possible light global loop. Dedicated winding in the OPT feeding back to the KT150 cathode. Best fit: with CF ×5 + UL + 29 dB, THD at 0.025–0.089 %. Close, not exact.
- H4 — Combination of UL + local NFB + global loop. Consistent with both figures, requires complexity not observed.
How to discriminate between hypotheses
| Check | Discriminates | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| OPT inspection: third winding? | H2/H4 vs. H1 | Low |
| Question to the manufacturer: "how much NFB, in dB, and of what type?" | H1 vs. H2 vs. H4 | Low (email) |
| Zout vs. frequency curve on two taps | H1 / H2 / H4 | Medium |
The rest of the measurements that help discriminate are in the verification plan of §6.1.
- Precedents: Icon ST30SE (measured): DF 7–9 UL, 15–17 triode HiFiNews · DF ≈ 6 Hi-Fi World. Fiio EA13: PP Class A, 17.7 kg, with documented buzz. Dared Saturn: −39 dB NFB with DF 6. Inconsistent.
- Three hypotheses: H1 (global NFB), H2 (cathode feedback), H4 (combination). Discarded: pure buffer and no NFB.
- With 100 mV: neither H1 nor H2 reaches 0.01 %. With 1000 mV, H1 revives. §4.5 and the video reinforce H2/H4. The model is sensitive to raUL and Raa: with raUL = 1.5–2 kΩ, H1 revives without CF.
6. Verification, conclusion and traceability
In a report whose finding is "we do not know X, Y, Z", the verification plan is the conclusion. This chapter separates the two layers: 6.1 the action (16 measurements, priorities, protocols, quick sheet for owners), 6.2 the state (what we have learned, what CANNOT be concluded, ND traceability table).
Measurements that would close the report
| # | Measurement / data point | Resolves | Kit | Priority |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | NFB depth and type (email) | Closes §4. Discriminates H1/H2/H4 | — | CRITICAL |
| 2 | Zout vs. frequency (2-load method) | Verifies DF ≈ 50 | Lab | CRITICAL |
| 3 | THD+N vs. power (full curve) | Verifies 0.01 % @ 18 W | Lab | CRITICAL |
| 4 | Real B+ and %UL | Class A ceiling and operating point | Owner | CRITICAL |
| 5 | Sensitivity 100 vs 1000 mV | If 1000 mV, H1 revives | — | CRITICAL |
| 6 | Listening at 10 cm from the transformer + Spectroid | Mechanical buzz | Owner | CRITICAL |
| 7 | OPT Lp + 20 Hz response at 1 W vs 18 W | Sizing of the custom OPT | Lab | CRITICAL |
| 8 | OPT: third winding? Real Raa | H2/H4 vs. H1; §4.3 model | Lab | HIGH |
| 9 | Comparative photo of the M1 and RS-1 OPTs | Specify how much has been redesigned | Owner | HIGH |
| 10 | Photo of the RF/EMI filter (reference) | Schaffner? Model | Owner | HIGH |
| 11 | Photo of the fuse holders (values) | Live+neutral or mains+B+? | Owner | HIGH |
| 12 | Measure real bias per KT150 | Verifies 130 mA | Owner | HIGH |
| 13 | IR thermometer after 2 h | Thermal margin of the transformer | Owner | HIGH |
| 14 | Square wave 1 kHz and 10 kHz | Stability under NFB | Lab | HIGH |
| 15 | Direct loop gain measurement | Real NFB depth | Lab | HIGH |
| 16 | Real weight on a scale | Confirms or refutes the 14 kg | Owner | HIGH |
Two kits, two profiles
| Kit | Components | Indicative cost | Measurements covered |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owner (minimum) | 1000 V DC multimeter, IR thermometer, smartphone with Spectroid/SpectrumView, two power resistors (8 Ω and 4 Ω) and some cable | ~€50–80 | 4, 6, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 16 |
| Laboratory | Focusrite Scarlett 2i2 (or similar), precision resistive loads, attenuator, oscilloscope, REW/ARTA | ~€300–400 | 2, 3, 7, 8, 14, 15 |
DF protocol
- 8 Ω and 4 Ω resistive load, sufficient power not to saturate.
- Frequencies: 20 Hz, 100 Hz, 1 kHz, 10 kHz, 20 kHz.
- Oscilloscope or True RMS. Two-load method (§4.2). Never in open circuit.
- Note the signal level of each measurement, because Zout can vary with excursion.
- Repeat on both taps (4 Ω and 8 Ω) if the device has them.
Why this protocol and not another: the two-load method avoids the overvoltage risk of the On-Off method and is consistent with the practice the manufacturer himself declares in §4.5. See §4.2 for the full methodological justification.
Hum protocol
- Listen at 10 cm from the power transformer after 1 h hot.
- Press the chassis with the palm: if the buzz drops, chassis-transformer coupling.
- Spectroid or SpectrumView app at 10 cm: 100 Hz peak = load buzz; 50 Hz peak = DC hum.
- IR thermometer: transformer >65 °C or OPT >50 °C after 2 h = no margin.
Quick sheet for owners (10 minutes)
If you have the RS-1 at home and are not going to measure, these seven checks are the minimum. Designed to print or copy to your phone.
| # | Check | How | Closes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Photo of the IEC C14 with filter reference | Photograph the socket inside or outside. Look for FN9222 / FN9280 / FN9244 silkscreen. | Filter brand and model. |
| 2 | Photo of fuse holders with values | Photograph the two caps. Check the engraved values. | Configuration and values. |
| 3 | Measure B+ at rest | 1000 V DC multimeter, switched on (caution). Wait 15 min warm-up. | Real B+. |
| 4 | Measure real bias per valve | Drop across each KT150 cathode resistor (typically 10 Ω). Expected 1.30 V. | Real bias. |
| 5 | Measure real weight on a scale | Compare with declared 14 kg. | Real weight. |
| 6 | Listening + Spectroid / SpectrumView app | Phone at 10 cm from the transformer after 1 h hot. Caution: do not touch the chassis with hot valves. | Transformer hum. |
| 7 | 20 Hz response at 1 W vs 18 W | Sound card + REW/ARTA + 8 Ω resistive load. | Sizing of the custom OPT. |
Safety before touching: never open the chassis plugged in; wait 10 min after switching off and discharge with 100 kΩ / 5 W down to < 20 V; do not measure in open circuit at the output (destroys the OPT); do not touch the KT150 pins while powered (450–500 V DC); do not touch the chassis if just switched off.
Synthesis of the report
The central finding. Under the §4.3 model, the THD 0.01 % at 18 W demands 49–54 dB of loop gain; the declared DF of ~50 corresponds to 31.7 dB as an impedance ratio. The available loop with 100 mV sensitivity is 21–29 dB. Neither H1 (0.1–0.45 %) nor H2 with cathode feedback (0.025–0.089 %) reaches 0.01 % without additional assumptions. If the sensitivity were 1000 mV, the loop would rise to 41–49 dB and H1 would revive.
Class A ceiling. 25 W with 130 mA bias require B+ = 384.6 V theoretical and ~478 V practical. The 450–500 V zone is not optimistic, it is what is needed.
Lineage and transformers. The RS-1 shares five exact parameters with the M1 (14 kg, 45×26×11 cm, 18 W @ 0.01 %, 100 kΩ, 100 mV). The manufacturer's video confirms that the OPTs are custom-made, different from those of the M1. The coincidence of weight suggests a moderate redesign in mass, but does not prove it: same weight does not imply same internal distribution. The 18 W @ 0.01 % is probably a family design goal, not an independent measurement of the RS-1.
Manufacturer's response. DF is calculated in the OPT design from 12 factors. The DF ≈ 50 figure is an average measured at 1 kHz with fixed resistive loads. It confirms the report's methodological suspicion, reinforces H2/H4 and leaves the question about NFB in dB open.
Hum risk. The power transformer can vibrate at 100 Hz due to rectifier peaks. The 1.5 mm steel chassis + solid wood panels inherited from the M1 can mitigate, but was not redesigned for the KT150. The verification is binary and without instrumentation.
Ethical closing. This report is not a measurement of the RS-1. The critical figures remain DECLARED until a specific unit is measured with a two-load protocol and a THD vs. power curve, and the hum is verified.
6.3 What CANNOT be concluded from this report
- On topology. It cannot be concluded that the RS-1 has no NFB (it does), that it is triode or pure pentode (it is UL), nor that it has no RF/EMI filter (it does). All three facts are confirmed by the manufacturer.
- On the declared figures. DF ≈ 50 might not hold at 20 Hz with reactive load; THD 0.01 % at 18 W is a single point, not a curve. The declared figures are not necessarily false or exaggerated, only unverified.
- On the 100 mV sensitivity. Its nature is not determined. If it were an erratum (1000 mV), the entire hypothesis tree changes.
- On NFB. The depth and type are not determined: ND. The manufacturer's email adds DF context, not loop context.
- On the cathode follower. It is not the cause of DF ≈ 50. That figure is decided in the output.
- On the class A ceiling. It does not imply that the 25 W is false. It only bounds the required minimum B+.
- On the 18 W @ 0.01 %. It is probably a family design goal inherited from the M1, not a measurement of the RS-1.
- On the transformers. The video confirms that the OPTs are custom-made, but not how much they have been redesigned. The chassis is probably inherited from the M1, but it is not explicitly confirmed. The OPT is not the same as the M1 (the video rules it out), but it might not be substantially larger.
- On sizing. Weighing 14 kg does not imply being undersized. The volumetric density (1.09 g/cm³) is the highest in the comparison group. The kg/W coincidence with the Jazz 90 is not significant.
- On hum and sound. It cannot be concluded that the RS-1 hums or does not hum. It cannot be concluded that it sounds better or worse than other SEs.
Traceability — what remains ND
| Block | Unknowns |
|---|---|
| Loop model (6 ND) | NFB depth in dB ND · NFB type ND · KT150 ra in UL ND · Real Raa ND · %UL ND · Phase margin and real loop ND |
| Custom OPT (5 ND) | Specifications (gap, N, Raa, Lp) ND · Primary inductance ND · Individual weight ND · Core section and air gap ND · 20 Hz response at 1 W vs 18 W ND |
| M1 lineage (3 ND) | Confirmation M1 chassis = RS-1 chassis PROBABLE · Precision of the OPT redesign ND · Origin of the 18 W @ 0.01 % PROBABLE inherited from M1 |
| Electrical and acoustic verification (12 ND) | Real B+ ND · Real bias per valve ND · Sensitivity 100 vs 1000 mV ND · Full THD curve ND · HV bank and filtering ND · Bias drift at 500 h ND · Real temperature of the OPTs ND · Real weight on a scale ND · Mechanical hum from the transformer ND, risk PROBABLE · Individual function of the 8 trimmers ND · Brand and model of the RF/EMI filter ND (probably Schaffner) · Configuration and fuse holder values ND · Presence of NTC or delay relay ND |
- 16 measurements, 7 CRITICAL. Two kits: owner (~€50–80) and laboratory (~€300–400). The question to the manufacturer about NFB is the cheapest and most discriminating. Quick sheet of 7 checks for owners.
- Central finding: the model estimates 49–54 dB for THD; 31.7 dB for DF 50. Neither H1 nor H2 reaches exactly 0.01 % with 100 mV. With 1000 mV, H1 revives.
- Ethical closing: this report is not a measurement. The critical figures remain DECLARED. The comparative photograph of the M1 and RS-1 OPTs closes §1.2 and §2.2 with a simple photo.
Interactive calculators — SPL and Zout
Two tools to interpret the report with your own numbers: one estimates the required power according to sensitivity, distance and target SPL; the other quantifies how much a high Zout colours the response over a realistic load.
SPL and required power calculator
Formulas: SPL_1W@d = sens − 20·log10(d) and P = 10^((target SPL − SPL_1W@d − factor)/10). Results per channel.
Response variation calculator by Zout
GLOSSARY — 11 TECHNICAL TERMS FROM THE REPORT
Glossary
Eleven terms that appear in §2.2, §2.3, §4.3 and the tables. For the reader arriving without prior electronics.
APPENDIX A — TECHNICAL QUESTIONNAIRE FOR JUAN CALATAYUD (JC VALVULAR)
Appendix A — Technical questionnaire
Questions to close the report's NDs. We start from four confirmed facts: NFB in all Acronos, UL in the valve models, IEC C14 RF/EMI filter in all, and custom OPTs in the RS-1 (the latter confirmed on video). Within each block, the questions are ordered from most to least important.
Block 1 — Feedback
- NFB depth.
How much NFB does the RS-1 have, in dB? What is the estimated loop gain?
- NFB type.
Global loop from the OPT secondary, or also local NFB (cathode feedback to the KT150 cathode)? If there is cathode feedback, does the custom OPT have a dedicated winding?
- 100 mV sensitivity.
Is it for a power stage or for an integrated with the potentiometer at maximum gain? If it is for a stage, it implies 43 dB closed, anomalously high. Or is it an erratum (1000 mV)?
- NFB contribution to DF and THD.
What fraction of the declared DF is due to NFB and what fraction to the custom OPT design? And of the THD?
- Compensation and stability.
Frequency compensation network? Phase and gain margins? Behaviour with 1 kHz and 10 kHz square wave?
Block 2 — Operating point and mode
- Real B+ and class A ceiling.
What is the real B+? With 130 mA bias, declaring 25 W in pure class A requires B+ = 384.6 V theoretical and ~478 V practical. If it is lower, the 25 W includes excursion outside class A.
- Full distortion curve.
The two declared points, at what frequency and load are they measured? Can the THD vs. power curve be published? Is the 18 W @ 0.01 % a measurement of the RS-1 or inherited from the M1? Does it comply with IEC 60268-3 (bandwidth and filter)?
- %UL.
What percentage of the primary tap is used for the KT150 screen?
- Bias and trimmers.
Is the 130 mA bias single or is there individual adjustment? What function does each of the 8 trimmers have?
Block 3 — Power supply, transformers and compatibility
- Custom output transformers.
The video confirms that they are different from the M1. Can you specify how? Weight of each OPT? Primary inductance? Raa? Gap? Core section? Is the same core section and window as the M1 OPT maintained or has it changed?
- Power transformer hum.
Has the mechanical hum at 100 Hz been verified? Is the transformer mounted on silentblocks?
- OPT primary inductance and real Raa.
It adjusts the §4.3 model and the OPT sizing.
- Lineage with the M1.
Is the RS-1 chassis the same as the M1's? Have only the OPTs and the bias circuit been changed, or is there more?
- Power supply filtering and RF/EMI filter.
How many filtering stages (C, LC, RC)? Total capacitance of the HV bank? Regarding the filter: brand and model? Common mode, differential, or both?
- Threaded fuse holders.
Do they protect live+neutral, mains+B+, or one per channel? Values?
- Noise and compatibility.
Residual noise with input shorted? Has it been tested with 89 dB or lower speakers?
- Operational data and support.
Net weight without packaging, consumption at rest and at full power? Is a schematic with test points provided?
APPENDIX B — MEASURING NFB WITHOUT OPENING THE CHASSIS
Appendix B — Measuring NFB without opening the chassis
The most critical ND of the report is the NFB depth in dB. There is an indirect method that does not require opening the amplifier, and that any technician with a bench can perform.
Physical principle
In an NFB loop, the ratio between the output signal and the signal fed back to the input is fixed by the feedback network (β). If a signal is injected at the OPT secondary with the amplifier switched off, and the attenuation at the input is measured, the β of the network is obtained. With the gain A known by another route, β·A is calculated.
Protocol
- Switch off and unplug. Wait 10 min.
- Access the positive speaker terminal (red). Do not open the chassis.
- Inject a signal with a generator or calibrated sound card. 1 kHz. 1 Vrms.
- Measure the signal at the corresponding RCA input. Amplifier switched off, passive network only.
- Note the attenuation: 20·log10(Vout/Vin) in dB.
- Repeat at 100 Hz, 1 kHz, 10 kHz to see the network curve.
Interpretation
| Measured attenuation (β) | Probable topology | Coherence with §4.3 |
|---|---|---|
| < −50 dB | Shallow global loop or no loop | H1 impossible |
| −30 to −50 dB | Typical global loop | H1 possible only with low raUL and/or 1000 mV |
| −15 to −30 dB | Deep loop + possible CF | H2 or H4 coherent |
| > −15 dB | Very deep loop | H1 revives without additional assumptions |
The measurement does not distinguish between global loop and cathode feedback: both appear as network attenuation. The distinction requires seeing the internal topology or asking the manufacturer.
Second measurement — closed-loop gain
- Switch on the RS-1, let it warm up for 15 min.
- Connect an 8 Ω resistive load.
- Inject 1 kHz at the input (10–100 mV).
- Measure Vout and Vin.
- Acl = Vout / Vin.
- With Acl ≈ A / (1 + βA) and β known, solve for A and β·A. 2–3 iterations are enough.
REFERENCES AND CREDITS
References and credits
Technical sources
- Fezz Audio · Titania MK2 report (nauscopio, V3.0.3). Sister publication that develops in its §5.3 the methodological framework for DF measurement (On-Off method vs two-load method, absence of fixed conditions in IEC 60268-3) and cites this Acronos RS-1 report in its Appendix D. From this document have been taken: the description of the two measurement methods, the car analogy, the Hi-Fi World figure for the Icon ST30SE (DF ≈ 6) and the pedagogical formulation of the catalogue/real distinction. (2026-10)
- JC Valvular — direct contact: NFB in all Acronos, UL in the valve models, IEC C14 RF/EMI filter in all. (2026-10)
- JC Valvular · public video of Juan Calatayud — declares that the RS-1 output transformers are different from those of the M1 and that they were commissioned custom-made with other specifications. Add video URL and timestamp (e.g. min 12:34). (2026) PENDING URL
- JC Valvular · response on DF — email from Juan Calatayud (§4.5): DF calculated in the OPT design from 12 factors; DF ≈ 50 measured at 1 kHz with resistive loads. (2026-10)
- JC Valvular — Acronos RS-1 commercial spec sheet: 25 W max., 18 W @ 0.01 %, 25 W @ 0.5 %, 130 mA bias, 195 W consumption, 20 Hz–40 kHz, 100 kΩ, 100 mV, 14 kg, 45×26×11 cm. (2026-10)
- JC Valvular · Acronos M1 Pura Clase A — official spec sheet of the predecessor (jcvalvular.com): 20 W max., 18 W @ 0.01 % at 1 kHz, 100 kΩ, 100 mV, 14 kg, 45×26×11 cm, KT120 in class A ultralinear. 2023-01
- Et Sona — RS-1 review (et-sona.com/post/jc-valvular-acronos). Genealogy with the M1, valve architecture, DF ≈ 50 and chassis construction details. (2026-10)
- Tung-Sol KT150 — official datasheet (tungsol.com). 70 W plate, 850 V pent. / 650 V triode, heater 1.75–2.0 A. Pentode A1 point: 400 V, 150–180 mA, 20 W with THD = 14 %. (2026-10)
- Philips/NXP EC86 — official datasheet (frank.pocnet.net). µ = 68, gm = 14 mA/V, ra ≈ 4.86 kΩ. Max plate 220 V. Equivalent 6CM4. (2026-10)
- Genalex / New Sensor — KT120 (60 W) and KT88 (42 W) datasheets.
- Schaffner — IEC C14 filter datasheets: FN9222, FN9280, FN9244. Leakage 0.2–0.5 mA; attenuation 20–60 dB between 150 kHz and 10 MHz. (2026-10)
- HiFiNews — Icon Audio ST30SE review, HFN 2019.11. Zout 0.85–1.17 Ω UL and 0.47–0.54 Ω triode; 28 W UL / 18 W triode. Weight 26 kg net / 28 kg packed. Consumption 177 W idle / 220 W full power. (2026-10)
- Hi-Fi World — Icon Audio ST30SE review. DF ≈ 6 figure for the same device that HiFiNews measures at 7–9 (UL) and 15–17 (triode). It illustrates that even two publications of the same device can give different figures depending on measurement conditions. (2026-10)
- Dared — Saturn Signature datasheet: 25 W/channel, NFB −39 dB, DF 6, THD 0.05 % at 4 W, weight 18 kg. Internally inconsistent.
- Fiio · EA13 — commercial spec sheet and user reports. PP Class A, 4× EL34, 220 W idle / 230 W full, 17.7 kg, 21.1 L. Documented mechanical buzz at 100 Hz. (2026-10)
- Fezz Audio · PA MK2 manual (60 W): 4× KT88, DF > 40, THD < 0.05 %. (2026-10)
- HiFiNews · Fezz Titania PA Evolution (January 2025): DF = 1, Zout 7.4–8.0 Ω over 20 Hz – 20 kHz. (2026-10)
- IEC 60268-3 — measurement methods for audio amplifiers: measurement bandwidth and filter for THD. It also describes the general procedure for measuring electrical parameters of amplifiers by the voltage-drop method, without fixing specific conditions (frequency, bandwidth, type of load) to express DF as a catalogue figure. (2026-10)
- Reference system — Crossover A v2.4 MR-A-01: 6 Ω nom, Zmin 4.9 Ω, 89 dB/W/m, listening at 3 m.
- Methodology. Formulas: Pmax = B+·Ibias/2 (Morgan Jones, Valve Amplifiers); Lp ≈ Raa/(2·π·fc); A = µ·RL/(RL+ra); Zout,cl = Zout,ol/(1+βA); ΔV ≈ I/(f·C); Lp ∝ N²·μef·A/l.
- Nauscopio comparative reports (2026-10) — Acronos P52, P52 vs Cayin Jazz 90, Fezz Audio Titania MK2.
- Edition V5.4.0 (2026-10). Refactored with the nauscopio V5.10 FINAL GSC + SOCIAL template. Changes from V5.3: JSON-LD with author.split name/alternateName and url https://nauscopio.wordpress.com/about/, about → Thing with @id, isPartOf, isAccessibleForFree, ISO 8601 with +02:00 zone, top-level ImageObject with width 1600 / height 925 / caption, publisher.logo updated to S1600 with dimensions, mainEntityOfPage with @id. First image migrated to S1600 with wrapper for lightbox, loading="eager" and 1600×925 dimensions, alt with og:image note.
→ . aria-pressed theme toggle to false. Added #s6-3 "What CANNOT be concluded" with anchor and TOC. Badge and footer updated to V5.4.0. GSC+SOCIAL checklist block at the start (commented). The technical contents, calculations, tables, glossary, appendices and references of V5.3 are preserved in full.Image credits
- General view of the Acronos RS-1: JC Valvular / Et Sona.
- Figures 1 and 2 (
Acronos-RS-1-pcboards.jpg,Acronos-RS-1-rear.jpg): JC Valvular.